Search Results
Search this site
484 results found with an empty search
- Human Nature Is Good Part 2 — I Didn't Mean To Hurt Your Feelings
Previously, I wrote about Mencius's theory on why human nature is good . His main idea is that all people have innate and natural feelings of Compassion (towards those suffering) Modesty (when over-praised) Right and wrong (an inner conscience) Shame (when doing wrong as deemed by the inner conscience) Icon Sources: 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 Mencius calls these "the four sprouts" because they need nurturing to become a strong motive force. If we neglect these four sprouts, and instead nurture weeds like ego and anger, then of course, those weeds will grow. However, the four sprouts will always be there and will never completely perish. Even someone with big weeds can still choose to nurture the four sprouts and "revive" their innate goodness. Understanding this idea is very important. When we truly believe that all humans have the potential for goodness, and that they just need us to water those four sprouts, we will treat people differently, which will then create results different as night and day in our relationships. I recently had an experience that confirmed Mencius's theory. Story This past week at school, we were doing school-wide cleaning in preparation for a big event next week. I was leading a grade 3 class to clean their classroom. I first wrote on the whiteboard a list of things to do: wipe the tables, scrub the chairs, erase marks off the walls, sweep the floors, wipe the baseboards, mop the floors, wipe the windows, wipe the whiteboard. I told them, "Today we have a big important mission! It's not going to be easy. We have to make this classroom spotless! Can you do it?" They said, "Yes!" I said, "OK, I split the mission into different tasks. Everyone, pick your task." The students all picked their own tasks. It felt like a good start because the kids were willing to do this mission and picked their own task. I didn't force them to do anything. For the first 10 minutes, everyone was doing their job. Then one of the students, Carol, told me, "I don't want to wipe tables anymore. It's boring. Can I do something else?" For context, Carol is known as a trouble student in the school who often doesn't listen to teachers. I told Carol, "You picked this job, so you have to make sure this job gets completed. If you want to do another job, then you have to find a classmate who is willing to swap with you." Carol then asked some other classmates, but no one was willing to swap with her. She then told me, "No one wants to swap with me. But I want to scrub chairs. That looks more fun." I said, "OK fine, but if you scrub chairs with Mary, then both of you need to wipe the tables afterwards." They both agreed. Later, Carol started disturbing others, putting soap water onto already clean tables, and throwing towels at others. The school rule is that teachers give two verbal warnings, and the third one results in a time-out. In the span of 10 minutes, I gave her two verbal warnings, and then finally a time-out. When I gave the time-out, it was near the end of school, so I said, "Time's up! Everyone except Carol, line up. I will take you out to the front door. Carol, you stay in the classroom and wait. I will tell your dad that you will come out late because you have a time-out." Carol said, "Please don’t tell my dad! If you tell him, he’ll tell my mom, and then…” She started tearing up. When I saw this, I thought it was a good teaching opportunity to let her know that this is how she makes us teachers feel when she doesn't listen to us. I said, “I know you’re upset right now, but have you ever thought that when I told you to not disturb others, to not throw towels around, and then you laugh it off like a joke, that you hurt my feelings?" She said, "I'm sorry…" Image Source: GPT I said, "What use is it to say sorry now? It's like if I use this push pin to poke a hole into this paper, when I pull it out, what's left? There's a hole. When you hurt my feelings, and then you say sorry after, there's still a hole. What can you do about it? How can you make it up? You think about it in the classroom. I'm going to take the other students out first." After a few minutes, she came out on her own to find me. I was surprised, and I almost wanted to say, "Didn't I tell you to wait in the classroom?" But I saw on her face that she looked very apologetic, so I didn't say anything. She said to me, "I know what I did was wrong, and I am really sorry for hurting your feelings. I promise I won't do it again. Please don't tell my dad." I then replied, "OK. I know you didn't truly mean to hurt my feelings. I forgive you this time, and I won't tell your dad. But you have to pinky promise to me that you will remember: not listening to the teacher will hurt our feelings. OK?" We then did a pinky promise, and I let her leave. Commentary I was quite surprised that Carol came out of the classroom by herself and apologized so sincerely. Just earlier that day, I saw Carol standing outside the classroom because she had a time-out by another teacher, and on her hand she wrote "Bad", and her face looked angry. I asked her, "Why do you have 'Bad' written on your hand?" She said, "Because I'm a bad girl." I said, "I don't think so. How about we erase that?" She said, "No." I then left her alone. Most people at school would think of Carol as self-centered, only wanting to play, hates being bored, and likes to imitate Kuromi (a cute, bad-girl version of Hello Kitty). Apparently, she used to be nice in the past, but after she got obsessed with Kuromi, she became a bad girl. I think Carol is a prime example of how people have innate goodness, but if we neglect those good sprouts and instead water the weeds (in this case, she got obsessed with Kuromi), then they become bad. Aside from Kuromi, her parents also told me that they set a bad role model at home because they will fight and scream, so the kids probably learned that from them. But despite all of these negative influences, her good sprouts are always there and can still be watered. If I had just said, "You're misbehaving. This is your third time. You have a time-out," that's not exactly watering her good sprouts. That's just reinforcing her idea that she's a bad girl. But when I told her, "I know you feel very upset right now, but did you know that this is how you make me feel when you don't listen to me?" Suddenly, her sense of morality arises. Deep down, she doesn't want to hurt my feelings. (This is also because I try to be nice to her, and I often help her to open her lunch container or do cleaning, so she feels bad for hurting my feelings.) Deep down, she has a sense of right and wrong, and she knows it's wrong to hurt the feelings of a teacher who is nice to her, so she naturally felt remorse. That's her innate goodness. When I said, "OK, I know you didn't mean to hurt my feelings, and I forgive you. Promise me that you won't do it again," that's watering her good sprouts. Of course, her bad habits have already grown, and changing those bad habits isn't easy. I wouldn't be surprised if she doesn't listen to teachers and gets more time-outs in the future, but we don't have to view these events as "bad" or dread them. Rather, they are learning opportunities to help her water good sprouts and slowly starve the weeds. With time and persistence, her good sprouts can become stronger than the weeds. Concluding Thoughts When others do bad things, do we water their good sprouts or their weeds? What about for ourselves? Weekly Wisdom #373
- A Likely Death...Or Not?
Image Source: Unsplash In June 2013, Ray Dalio found out from his physician at John Hopkins Hospital that he has a disease called Barret’s esophagus with high-grade dysplasia. Basically, that means he has early-stage cancer in his esophagus (throat). If it develops into real cancer (about 15% chance), then they would have to remove his esophagus. Unfortunately, Dalio’s case had complications that prevented such a surgery, which means he would die within 3 to 5 years. Dalio started planning for his death, but he also wanted to learn from other experts aside from his doctor. As a billionaire, Dalio is able to get access to the best doctors in the country, so he got his physician to set up visits with four other experts on this disease. The first expert was the head of thoracic surgery at a major cancer hospital. She told Dalio that contrary to what his first physician said, there is a surgery that could cure him. However, that surgery would have a 10% chance of death and a 70% chance of a crippling outcome. But chances are, he would live, so she recommended the surgery. Dalio, being the humble and careful person he was, decided to call his first physician from John Hopkins right there on the spot and have the two experts discuss. He noticed the two experts were very focused on being courteous to each other, and he was concerned that they weren’t prioritized about finding the best solution. Still, it was clear that they had different views, and listening to them helped Dalio understand the situation better. The day after, Dalio met with a world-renowned specialist at another hospital. This doctor told him that his condition would basically be no problem as long as he went to the hospital for an endoscopic examination every 3 months. The doctor explained that if they can cut out new growth of cancer cells before it metastasized into the bloodstream, then he’d be okay. In other words, he wouldn’t die if he got the cancer; His life would be pretty normal except for the occasional hospital visits. Dalio reflected that over the past 48 hours, he had gone from a likely death sentence to a likely possible cure that would likely cripple him, then to a simple and slightly inconvenient cure. Which doctor was right? Dalio and his first physician met two other world-class specialists, and they both agreed with the third doctor about the scoping procedure, so Dalio agreed to do it. They clipped some tissue from his esophagus and tested it in the laboratory. Later, they found out there wasn’t any high-grade dysplasia at all! From this experience, Dalio reflected on the importance of checking information against multiple experts to raise your chances of finding out the truth. Source: Principles by Ray Dalio
- Any Situation Can Be A Good Situation
When the great ancient Greek philosopher Socrates was still single, he shared a small room, which was barely eight square meters, with a few friends. Life was cramped and inconvenient, yet he was always cheerful and smiling. Someone asked him, “With so many people squeezed together, it must be hard to even turn around. What’s there to be so happy about?” (Pause. How do you think Socrates responded?) Socrates replied, “When friends live together, we can exchange ideas and share our feelings anytime. Isn’t that something to be happy about?” Later, one by one, his friends got married and moved out. Socrates was left alone in the room, but he remained just as content. (Pause. Why do you think Socrates was still happy?) He said, “I have so many books! Each book is a teacher. To be surrounded by so many teachers and to be able to learn from them anytime—how could I not be happy?” Image Source: GPT A few years later, Socrates got married and moved into a seven-story building. His home was on the ground floor, the worst location in the building. People upstairs often dumped dirty water, threw down dead rats, old shoes, and all kinds of trash. Yet Socrates still appeared cheerful and at ease. Someone asked curiously, “You live in such a place and still feel happy?” (Pause. How do you think Socrates responded?) Socrates said, “Of course! Do you know how many advantages there are to living on the first floor? For example, I can step inside as soon as I open the door—no need to climb stairs. Moving things is easy and effortless. When friends visit, they don’t have to knock on doors floor by floor to find me. And what pleases me most is that I can plant clusters of flowers and rows of vegetables right outside. The joy from that is endless!” A year later, Socrates gave his first-floor room to a friend who had an elderly relative with limited mobility. He moved to the seventh floor—the top of the building. Yet again, he remained cheerful as ever. Someone asked teasingly, “Sir, are there many benefits to living on the seventh floor too?” (Pause. How do you think Socrates responded?) Socrates smiled and said, “Of course there are! For one thing, going up and down the stairs several times a day is great exercise and good for my health. The lighting is excellent, so reading and writing don’t strain my eyes. No one lives above me, so it’s peaceful day and night.” Later, that same person met Plato, one of Socrates’ students, and said, “Your teacher is always so happy, but I really don’t think the places he’s lived in were that great.” Plato replied, “A person’s happiness doesn’t depend on their surroundings, but on their state of mind.” ( Story source ) My Experience Everyone wants to be happy, but most people think that in order to be happy, the outside world needs to be a certain way. That's a certain mindset for suffering because the outside world often is not the way people want it to be. The good news is, we can learn to adjust our thinking and mindset so that no matter what the outside situation is, we can maintain our peace and happiness, just like Socrates. In my experience, I've found three ways to reframe any situation into a good situation: Find the good Focus on improving ourselves from it Focus on setting a good example for others 1: Find the good When something bad happens, we often zoom in on the bad. But chances are, there are also good aspects to the situation too. We just have to jump out of the negativity hole and look for the good. For example, recently I went to visit the doctor's office, and the doctor was late by 30 minutes, and I was 14th in line. I was getting a bit annoyed that they didn't open on time, and that I had to wait in line for so long. What could be good about this? Well, I could be grateful that I have free healthcare, that I don't have any serious illness (a lot of the other people in line seemed to be less healthy comparatively), that I have the time to wait, and that I can still do work on my phone while I wait. So that's exactly what I did, and I felt pleased that I was able to remain calm and make good use of the unexpected inconvenience. 2: Focus on improving ourselves from it Socrates once said, "Just as one person delights in improving his farm, and another his horse, so I delight in attending to my own improvement day by day." Image Source: GPT It's human nature to delight in one's own growth and improvement, so rather than focusing on how the external situation is not what we wanted it to be, we can focus on how we can improve ourselves from it. If we can grow from this difficulty, then we'd feel happy and grateful for it. For example, the doctor being late is annoying to me. Why? Well, I expect others to be on time. I don't have much to do while waiting in line, and I don't like wasting time. How could I reframe the situation so that it becomes a good thing? Well, I could tell myself, "This is exactly what I need!" Why? Because if I want to live a happy life, I have to train my mind to view any situation as good, and that requires me to encounter challenges and practice using them. This situation is a challenge for me to let go of demands towards others and instead be tolerant and understanding towards others. Maybe the doctor had a family emergency today. Maybe the doctor was feeling sick today but still dragged himself to the office to help patients in need. It doesn't matter what the actual situation is, what I choose to believe about it determines how I feel and how I treat the doctor when I see him. From another perspective, being late is a very common thing. I am late sometimes too. If I get really upset at others for being late, then I am basically setting myself up to be upset frequently in life. That's not other people's problem, that's my problem. So I should learn from every experience and have a back-up plan for when others are late. When I told myself these things, I could more calmly wait in line, and I was happy that I improved my tolerance and patience from this experience. 3: Focus on setting a good example for others We all want others to be better and advise them on their faults. But whether or not other people listen to us depends on whether we've set a good example for them. If I tell others to be more patient and tolerant, but I'm always complaining and impatient, then others will think, "Who are you to tell me to be more patient? You should fix yourself first!" While waiting at the doctor's office, my mother was also impatient. At one point, she even asked if we should just leave and come back another day because there were so many people lined up and there was nowhere to sit. I focused on staying calm and said, "Well, we're already here, and we have time today, and the weather is only going to get worse as winter progresses, so why not just wait a bit longer? Besides, you can do your Buddha chanting meditation here. It's not that big of a difference than doing it at home, right?" She decided to listen, and we got it over with that day. Since I myself was focused on being patient and making productive use of the situation, I was able to help my mom do the same. If I was also annoyed, I might've agreed with my mother, and we'd both just go home in a bad mood. Later, I suggested to my mom that we visit a Chinese medicine doctor as well, and she got annoyed that I was giving her too much stuff to do, that she wants to just stay at home and finish reading a book that she's been trying to finish for a long time. Again, I focused on cultivating my own patience and understanding, and I told her it's no rush, and she doesn't have to go see a Chinese medicine doctor if she doesn't want to. The next day, she apologized for getting annoyed when I was trying to help her with that suggestion. I then advised her and said, "The matter of going to see a Chinese medicine doctor isn't the problem. The problem is our state of mind. You could calmly say to me, 'I'm very busy trying to finish this book right now. Seeing a Chinese medicine doctor is not urgent. Can we talk about this after I'm done reading my book?" Since she can see that I'm often trying to cultivate my calmness and patience, she was willing to accept my advice. Therefore, by focusing on improving ourselves, we naturally also set a good example for others, so that when we do advise them in the future, they are more likely to listen to us. Conclusion As Plato said, our happiness is not dependent on our outside circumstances, but rather on our mind and way of thinking. Image Source: GPT We can turn negative situations around by choosing to look for the good, focus on improving ourselves, and focus on setting a good example for others. These three methods are interrelated and we can use all three at the same time. What are some "bad" situations that you encountered recently? How could you reframe them into good situations? Weekly Wisdom #372
- Be A Coach, Not A Police Officer
Recently, a teacher colleague discussed some class problems with me: "I noticed that some students in my kindergarten class like to police classmates and hate admitting mistakes, especially Jenny. For example, when Joe accidentally hit Carol with his elbow while coloring, Jenny came to me and said Joe hit Carol. But it was an accident, and Joe even said sorry right away. I know other teachers might just tell the students to directly talk to each other rather than personally scold the wrongdoer, but I'm not sure if this is a good idea. Maybe it would help them develop their social skills, but maybe it's better for the teacher to get involved. Also, yesterday it was Jenny's turn to turn off the lights when leaving the classroom, but she forgot. I often have to remind her, but yesterday I didn't. I asked Carol to help turn off the lights instead. Later, Carol said to Jenny, 'By the way, you forgot to turn off the lights when we left the classroom, but don't worry, I helped you turn it off.' Jenny responded, 'No I didn't. I turned off the lights.' I told Jenny, 'Maybe you remembered wrong. I noticed you didn't turn off the lights, so I asked Carol to help.' She said, 'No, I remember very clearly that I turned off the lights.' It seems to me like Jenny hates to admit mistakes, and I don't know what to do with her. Do you have any advice?" I replied: "I lack expertise and experience with kindergarteners, so I don't know if I can give any good advice. But I'll try to offer something that hopefully can help. Firstly, about whether or not we should let students work it out themselves instead of tattletaling, I think the problem is not the matter, the problem is the intention. If Jenny comes tell me that a classmate did something wrong, I would ask her, 'OK. Why are you telling me this? Are you trying to help them correct their faults? Or do you just want them to get punished?' The point is that we should be trying to help our classmates correct their faults. Then I would say to Jenny privately, "OK, so our goal is to help them correct their faults. Let's wait until recess or after lunch. I'll tell the other classmates to go play, and I'll ask you and Joe to stay behind in the classroom. Then you can politely tell Joe, 'Today you hit Carol, and I think you should apologize to Carol for that.' If Joe doesn't know how to respond, then I'll tell Joe, "Jenny is very respectful towards you! She waited until the other classmates left to give you important advice. What should we say when others try to help us improve?" Then Joe would know to say "Thank you." Later when the class is back, I might tell the class what happened and praise Jenny for helping Joe to correct a fault, and I'd also praise Joe for being humble and accepting Jenny's advice. This way, the whole class learns that advising others respectfully and accepting advice humbly are good deeds. I would also tell the class, "Mistakes are only bad if we don't learn from them. But if we learn from our mistakes, then we turn them into valuable lessons. And that's awesome!" Of course, saying this is one thing, but we have to believe in it and guide our students to learn from each mistake and praise them for it. Only then would they truly internalize it. Icon Sources: 1 , 2 , 3 As for why Jenny always polices others and hates to admit mistakes, I wonder if that might be related to her parents? Maybe her parents often police her and tell her what she did is wrong or not good enough, so then she always wants to defend herself, and she starts copying her parents' behavior towards classmates." The teacher replied, "Yes, I think that is the case with her mother. Joe's mother is similar. I often tell Jenny and Joe that they shouldn't police classmates. The teacher can tell students their faults because it's the teacher's job, but classmates shouldn't do it. But I think they are copying me too." I said, "Right. Again, I would say that the problem is not the matter of telling others their faults. The problem is the intention and energy behind our actions. If we are policing our students and telling them 'You shouldn't do that', 'Don't do that', 'Say sorry', etc., what's our intention? Our intention will determine our facial expression, tone of voice, and body language, and kids will learn that. Some teachers are very demanding towards kids because they feel that their kids' behavior reflects their teaching, and they want to have a good reputation in the eyes of other teachers and parents. Some other teachers demand good behavior from kids because they want class to be smooth, and they dislike dealing with trouble. Whatever the reason is, being demanding towards kids for selfish reasons will create opposition. When we oppose kids, as if their behavior is unrelated to us, as if they choose to disrespect us, then we will blame them for not behaving in the way we want them to. When blamed, they will want to make excuses or deny fault. So we have to correct our intentions and attitude. When we change ourselves, we naturally change the way others respond to us. That's why there's a Chinese proverb that goes, 'When things don't go according to your wishes, reflect on yourself.' If our intention is to help them improve, then we would act more like a coach, not a police officer. We could tell them that there is a good learning opportunity here. For example, when Jenny forgot to turn off the lights, I would first remind Jenny to turn off the lights. Later, I might ask Jenny, 'Let's turn our past mistake into a useful lesson. How can you make sure you remember to turn off the lights next time without the teacher reminding you?' If she has trouble thinking of a solution, I might say to the class, "We are all one team. We need to help each other out. Right now Jenny is having trouble thinking of a way to remember to turn off the lights next time. Can anyone think of a solution?" If no one in the class has any ideas, then I can give suggestions. This is turning the problem into a learning opportunity. This is what a coach would do, but a police officer wouldn't." Icon Sources: 1 , 2 The teacher replied, "I think it's quite insightful when you said I should focus on changing myself, not on changing others. So at home, in the morning, my nine-year-old daughter is really slow to get ready. Sometimes I start nagging at her and rushing her because I'm worried that if I don't, her dad will get angry and start shouting at her. How can I change myself then? If I am very calm and don't make a big deal out of it, her dad will shout at her." I said, "Right. So do you think your daughter has learned your nagging and your dad's shouting?" She said, "Yes. I noticed that she likes to point out our faults, and sometimes she'll shout angrily too." I replied, "There's a quote that goes, 'Children don't do what you say, they do what you do.' In the situation you mentioned, I would probably rush my daughter too. But if my intention is to help her, not to blame her, not because I'm scared of the spouse shouting, then I would be gentle but firm. People can feel our energy. If she is still slow at getting ready, and then my spouse starts shouting, then that's also a learning opportunity. I could calmly ask my spouse to be a bit more gentle and patient. Later, at an appropriate time, I could have a conversation with my daughter. I would ask her why she is so slow. Is it because she's tired? Or she doesn't want to go school? Or just lazy? Based on her reason, we can then think of a solution. This way, she feels that we are trying to help her, not blame her. I would also ask her to reflect on how her behavior made others feel. How did it make your parents feel? Do you want your mom and dad to feel anxious or angry? Is that a nice way to treat your parents? Given that it's not nice, how could you do better next time? Let's make a plan. If mom and dad often get impatient, then mom and dad need to improve too. We can have a contest. You work on being faster in the morning, and if you are on time, then you get a star. If you are slow, then it's our challenge to remain calm and patient towards you. If we can do that, then we get a star. Let's do a competition and see who can get to 10 stars first. We can exchange 10 stars for a treat of our choice. Anyway, that's just an idea. There's no one correct answer. As long as our intentions are proper, the results will naturally align themselves." She replied, "Wow I never thought of it that way. OK, I guess my next step is to work on correcting myself, and then my daughter and students will naturally improve too." I said, "Yes, I'm exactly the same. Honestly, it's easy to give advice to someone else. It's a completely different challenge to actually do it ourselves. I feel like I nag too much too. I don't spend enough time calmly following up with students after matters happen to turn problems into lessons, and I often blame students too. We're all on a journey of self-improvement, so let's support each other along the way!" Weekly Wisdom #371
- Great Trust Transcends Words
Image Source Recently, a teacher colleague discussed a student situation with me about two elementary school children. She said to me: "Yesterday at lunch, John was provoking Chelsea by showing off his snacks to her, and Chelsea was quite jealous and upset that she didn't have such snacks. She then threw a broccoli at John. When I saw this, I got very angry and scolded Chelsea for being disrespectful and throwing food. She felt I was being unfair because John started it. But I told her you don't have to react to John, and you certainly don't have to throw food across the table. I told her since she disrespects food, she cannot eat the rest of her lunch, and if she's hungry this afternoon, that's the consequence she has to experience. Chelsea accepted responsibility and the punishment. Later in the afternoon, Chelsea told me she was hungry. Although I felt bad for her and wanted to give her food, I felt like I needed to keep my word and authority, so I told her that's the punishment for disrespecting food. Do you think I was too harsh on her?" Note: Although not everyone is a teacher, most of us are probably current parents or future parents, and we may encounter similar situations with children at home. Even if we are not parents or teachers, we may have to mediate conflict for others, so we can still learn something useful from this case. If you were in this teacher's situation, what would you do? After you have your own thoughts, you can continue reading. I responded: "First, I think the school is very fortunate to have a teacher like you who cares so much about the students' character development. A lot of other schools and teachers might just tell them to stop making a fuss and finish their lunch quietly. But you saw that this was a teaching opportunity, and you used it to teach the students an important lesson about not responding to provocations and being respectful towards food. Our school puts their character development first, so I really respect what you did. Since you are asking me if you were too harsh on her, I can infer that deep down, you felt you were too harsh on her. I think that's your sense of conscience speaking. You mentioned that you got very angry at Chelsea. For me, if I notice that my anger is rising, I try to shut my mouth and leave the situation. That's because I know that if I have anger or other negative emotions, I will make the situation worse by speaking. Only with a calm mind can we make the situation better. Ultimately, we should talk to them about this situation and give appropriate punishment and education. But we need to do it with the intention of helping them, and we can't mix in feelings of anger or blame. Now you are calm, so if you could re-do that whole situation, how might you do it differently?" She said: "Yeah you're right. After I went home last night, I still kept thinking about Chelsea and felt bad for making her hungry. I also remembered that scolding kids while they're eating is not good for their digestion. But I wanted to be prompt in responding to the problem. I'm afraid that if I just let it slip by, the effect wouldn't be the same. Also, to be honest, I was trying to scare John more so than Chelsea. I know that John started this, and when Chelsea threw the broccoli, I think John would have responded by throwing food too, so I immediately went over and was very strict on Chelsea to signal John that such behavior is not allowed. But I think John just smirked, so it didn't have the effect I was hoping for. If I had to re-do the situation, maybe I wouldn't try to scare John by being strict with Chelsea. But when Chelsea said she was hungry in the afternoon, I don't know if I would give her something to eat. These kids are spoiled and self-centered as it is, if we give a punishment and then retract it, then wouldn't I be breaking a promise that we both agreed to? And kids might think that they can get whatever they want as long as they plead?" I said: "I agree that you shouldn't try to scare John by being strict with Chelsea. Each person should have a consequence proportionate to their offense. John mocked Chelsea and tried to get her to be jealous. He should have some sort of consequence for that. Chelsea chose to respond by throwing broccoli at John. She got a corresponding punishment that she felt was fair, which was why she didn't argue with you. But maybe later today, you should have a chat with John to tell him that provoking others is not acceptable. If I were you in that situation, I wouldn't scold them while they are eating because I don't want to ruin their mood and digestion during lunch. I would tell them to finish their lunch quietly, and then have them come talk to me privately during lunch recess. They might complain that they want to have recess, in which case I'll say you guys misbehaved while eating, so we need to have a chat. I'm sure they can sense that I'm not venting anger on them because I still let them eat their lunch, but at the same time, they know that I'm principled, and I'm not letting them get away with any behavior that crosses the line. During the chat, I'll say the things you said to Chelsea, and I'll also tell John that provoking others is a very serious offense. Maybe I would give them both detention, and John would need to write an apology letter to Chelsea, and Chelsea would need to tell me what she did wrong. If I think all the kids need to hear the conversation, I could make an announcement later and let everyone know that provoking others or throwing food is not allowed at school and that there will be consequences. You mentioned that you didn't want to give Chelsea food in the afternoon because you're afraid that you'll be breaking a promise. This reminds me of a quote from the Record on Education : 'Great trust transcends words.' In other words, using words and contracts is a low level of trust. A high level of trust transcends words. A high level of trust means I trust that you have my best intentions at heart. Maybe at lunch, when Chelsea agreed to the punishment, she didn't foresee how hungry she would be later. If she comes to me later and tells me she's hungry, I would ask her, 'On a scale of 1 to 10, how hungry are you? Can you last until the end of school?' If she is truly starving and can't even focus in class, then I would give her something to eat. I'm sure she wouldn't think the teacher is breaking his word. She would feel that the teacher truly cares for her. Or if she says, 'My hunger level is 7. I don't know if I can last until the end of school', then I might give her some juice to drink. That's technically not breaking my word since juice is not food, but it still gives her some energy. The reason I can think of such a solution is I'm not preoccupied with protecting my reputation; rather, I am focused on what's best for her." The teacher asked, "But what if she's not actually that hungry, and she lies and says she's really hungry, and then she thinks she got away with lying to get what she wanted?" I said, "You have to make a judgment call, and the way to see things clearly is to be focused purely on her wellbeing. If you're worried about things like your authority or being deceived, then you won't be able to focus on her, and you won't see clearly. If you are purely focused on her, then you will be able to judge from her facial expression, her tone of voice, her body language, her reactions, all of that, you'll be able to judge with a certain level of confidence her true situation, and then you can make the appropriate decision. From another angle, so what if you get deceived here? If I were Chelsea, and I lied and told my teacher that I'm very hungry, and then the teacher gave me food, maybe I might think I'm very clever. But eventually, I'll realize that this teacher really cares about me, and I'll feel bad for lying to such a nice teacher, and I'd try to treat that teacher better in the future. Ultimately, there is never one correct course of action. As long as we have the proper intentions, the results will naturally align themselves. Although we can't change the past, you can still create the future. Chelsea is still a kid, and I'm sure she didn't make a big deal out of what happened. She looked normal and happy today. Maybe you can talk to her later today and tell her that you're very impressed and proud of her that she could endure hunger all afternoon yesterday and then give her a hug." The teacher nodded and thanked me for the advice. I told her, "Honestly, it's much easier to give advice than to actually do it. Even though I can say this advice, if I were in your actual situation, I probably wouldn't be able to do better. I just recently lost my patience with some other kids. That's why it's helpful to get advice from neutral third parties who don't have emotional baggage around the situation. You have a lot of strengths that I don't have. We're all working on improving ourselves, so let's keep supporting each other!" Weekly Wisdom #370
- Health Advice From Doctors At A Chinese Medicine Hospital
Welcome to this article series on Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). The aim of this series is to provide you with foundational and practical knowledge of TCM that you can use to improve your own health at home in daily life. The recommendations in this series are simple, accessible, and mostly free. After all, good health should be something that is accessible to everyone! Here is a clickable table of contents for this series: Introduction and Foundation The Five Elements Profiles Food and Cooking The Five Major Organs The Nine Body Constitutions The Body Clock Common Treatments from a Practitioner My Experience with TCM Health Advice From Doctors At A Chinese Medicine Hospital Sleep Tips from Traditional Chinese Medicine Emotions and Health This article is Part 9: Health Advice From Doctors At A Chinese Medicine Hospital. This summer, I had the opportunity to learn and shadow at a traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) hospital in Inner Mongolia called Shen Nong Hospital. This opportunity came about because my TCM doctor, Dr. Kun Liu , goes back to her hometown in Inner Mongolia every year to visit her family, and this year, I happen to be in China at the same time. She knows I'm a TCM enthusiast, so she asked if I'm interested in coming to learn at her father's hospital for a week. I totally jumped at the opportunity. (Me in front of Shen Nong Chinese Medicine Hospital) That week I learned a lot, and it's one of the coolest experiences I've ever had. I wrote a detailed blog post about my experience here , but I know not everyone is into the details of TCM, so in this article, I'll just share some PSA (public service announcement) type health advice that I got from the doctors there. In summary, they are Have good posture After sitting for a while, get up and do some neck and shoulder stretches Exercise enough Eat a balanced diet suited to your body constitution Avoid AC and cold wind directly blowing onto the skin, especially the neck and upper back Cultivate positive emotions Icon Sources: 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 Basically, I asked the doctors in each department there what the most common illnesses they treat are, and how people can prevent them. After all, we should take advantage of healthy times to prevent illness. By the time we do get ill, regret is already too late. Massage Department: Neck, Shoulders, and Digestion In the adult massage department, the doctor said, "90% of my patients come to me for shoulder and neck problems. I'm doing shoulder and neck massage almost all day. Sometimes I'll get patients with lower back problems or local injuries." In terms of prevention, he said, "Prevention is really simple. Most people get shoulder and neck problems due to bad desk posture for a prolonged period of time. So #1 is to have good desk posture. #2 is after sitting down for a while, maybe 30-60 minutes, get up and stretch your neck and do some shoulder exercises for a few minutes. #3 don't have AC blowing directly onto your neck and back because that cold wind will enter the body and cause the muscles there to become tense, creating problems long-term." I asked if there are any specific exercises to do. He said, "No, any are fine. It's not that complicated." He then showed me some basic exercises, and indeed, it's just what you'd expect if you searched up "neck and shoulder exercises" on the internet. In the child massage department, the doctor said most kids come to him for digestive issues (yes, TCM massage can aid digestion, and I do it for myself every day). I was surprised but also not surprised. Surprised by the fact that children already have digestive issues. But then not surprised because of the big fast food and takeout culture in modern society. This signals that as a society, we need to be more conscientious of our dietary habits. Less processed foods, fried foods, and restaurant foods. More natural foods, vegetables, and home-cooked foods. For more on healthy eating, check out this article: Healthy Eating 101 and TCM: Food and Cooking . Moxibustion Department: Coldness and Digestion Moxibustion is when a practitioner burns moxa sticks to apply heat onto specific acupoints or areas of the body. The body then absorbs the heat and herbal qualities of the moxa. Image Source The human body needs heat, or what TCM calls "Yang", to function, and people who are deficient in Yang tend to have symptoms such as getting cold very easily, having cold hands and feet, easily tired, easily catches colds and flus, loose stools or diarrhea, and having a white coating on the tongue. I asked the head doctor of the moxibustion department what the most common illnesses he treats are. He said that people usually come here for one of two reasons: deficiency in Yang and cold stomach. People can get deficient in Yang due to many factors, such as climatic factors (i.e., cold winter), poor diet, overwork, and old age (people's Yang energy decreases with age). In terms of diet, eating too much cold-natured foods, cold-temperature foods, and raw foods all harm the stomach. Cold-temperature foods harm the stomach because the stomach needs heat to digest foods, and eating really cold foods will shock the body, causing it to suddenly need to direct a lot of heat towards the stomach, which is very stressful. Raw foods (e.g., raw salads) also harm the stomach because it is much harder to digest raw foods compared to cooked and soft foods, so raw foods create more "wear and tear" on the stomach. Eating too much cold-natured foods will make the body cold, which includes the stomach, which of course reduces digestive power. In TCM, foods can be classified into five natures: cold, cool, neutral, warm, and hot. Image Source For example, most fruits are cold, so eating a lot of raw fruits can lead to diarrhea. Of course, an appropriate amount is fine, especially in hot weather. Every person's body is different, so we cannot use one standard for everyone. But if you have a cold body constitution, then you should eat less cold-natured foods and more warm-natured foods, such as ginger, pepper, garlic, cinnamon, pumpkin, walnuts, etc. If you do eat cold-natured foods, you can mix in some warm-natured ones. For example, seafood tends to be cold, which is why Japanese people pair seafood with wasabi and ginger. Of course, not everyone has a cold body constitution. Some people have an overly hot body constitution, which might lead to symptoms such as always feeling hot, hot hands and feet, dry mouth and nose, dry stools or constipation, oily face, acne (no wonder I used to get acne after eating fast food), bad breath, and a yellow coating on the tongue. This can be due to excess fried foods (deep-fried foods are very high in Yang), spicy foods, and alcohol. My doctor mentioned that a lot of westerners have excess Yang because of eating too much fast food, especially fried chicken (a double-whammy on Yang). For people who have excess Yang, eating some cold-natured foods would be helpful. The goal is always balance. Healthy eating in TCM encompasses more than just warm or cold natures, and if you're interested in learning more, you can read this article: TCM Food And Cooking . I'll just mention a few more tips here: Go for a short walk after meals to aid digestion. Don't sit down right away. Eat until 70-80% full. Eating too full hurts the stomach. Eat at regular times. Try to eat a variety of flavors. It's easy to eat sweet and salty in western foods. Try to add some sour, spicy, aromatic, and bitter flavors into the diet. Each organ responds to different flavors. Eat a variety of colors. Each organ responds to different colors. Cupping Department: Colds and Emotions Cupping is when a practitioner applies suction cups to draw out and clean out toxins from the body. The color left behind indicates different health situations. For example, light pink is healthy, darker colors indicate stronger stagnation, red indicates heat, and purple indicates coldness. Sometimes the cup becomes damp inside, which indicates dampness in the body. Image Source I asked the cupping practitioner what patients usually come see her for. She said, " Usually for coughs, back problems, and liver stagnation." Coughs and colds are a bit unavoidable. We all catch a cold once in a while. But I learned that aside from viruses, we can also catch a non-contagious type of cold when the body goes from a really hot environment to a cold one. This actually happened to me in Fuzhou, China. In the summer, it's 40 degrees outside, but all the rooms are air conditioned. I was moving a lot of boxes and furniture between rooms, so I went from 40 degrees to suddenly 20 degrees, back and forth. I was sweating a lot, so all my pores were open, then I enter an AC room, and that cold air directly enters my pores. Moreover, I was a bit overworked and sleep-deficient, resulting in a weakened immune system. When the external pathogen (in this case, the cold wind from the AC) is stronger than the body's defensive energy, the person gets ill, and I indeed caught a cold. I also noticed that many people in Fuzhou wear a light wind-breaker jacket to prevent AC from directly blowing onto their skin. I was very intrigued at first because I've never seen people do that in the west. But now I know that if someone is sitting still, and there's AC blowing directly onto the skin, especially the neck and upper back, it's very easy for the cold wind to enter and accumulate in the body, which will eventually create problems. My doctor also said that the majority of the cold-natured patients that she sees tend to sit in an office environment all day, meaning they lack exercise, and exercise creates Yang. They also have AC blowing on their bodies all day. So it's important for us to get up and do some simple exercises after sitting for a while, to dress warm enough in an AC room, and avoid AC directly blowing onto the skin, especially the neck and upper back. Back problems are also related to back posture and lack of exercise, though sometimes they can be due to local injuries. I didn't ask more about this one to the doctor, so I won't say that much. Liver stagnation is usually due to emotional disharmony, such as anger, frustration, stress, and anxiety. According to TCM, external pathogens need to go through many defensive layers before they can reach our internal organs. However, emotions directly and immediately affect our organs' health. I never realized how serious emotional management was for my health until I learned TCM. So if we want to prevent liver stagnation and other health problems, it's very important to cultivate happiness, calm, and peaceful emotions. Regularly do activities like yoga, tai chi, going for walks in nature, or whatever helps you to feel calm, relaxed, peaceful, and happy. The topic of healthy emotions is a big one, and if you want to read more, you can check out my past articles on stress management , relationship management , and inner joy . Conclusion When we are healthy, we might not think too much about preventing illness. But after we get ill and feel really uncomfortable and painful, we think, "Ah! If only I knew this would happen earlier, I would have done more to prevent it!" So let's take advantage of healthy times to guard against illness. In summary, the doctors at the hospital recommended: Posture is very important for our neck and back. Practice good posture. After sitting down for a while, get up and do some quick neck and shoulder exercises. Exercise enough. Avoid having AC blow directly onto your skin, especially the neck and upper back. Eat a healthy and balanced diet. Excess cold and excess heat all create problems. Healthy emotions are key to a healthy body. Manage negative emotions, cultivate positive emotions, and nurture good relationships. A big thanks again to Dr. Kun Liu and all the doctors at the Shen Nong Hospital, and I hope readers will find some of this advice useful!
- On Advising Others For Big Decisions
Recently, a good friend told me she's thinking about divorce. This is a very big matter, and my purpose with this article is not to discuss the pros and cons of a divorce, but rather how we should support and guide others (and ourselves) when making big decisions, whether that be a divorce, choosing a partner, shifting careers, making a big purchase, moving residence, etc. I've previously written about principles for wise decisions , and this article will apply those principles in an actual matter. Image Source: ChatGPT 1: What Can We Actually Say? The first thing we need to do is consider whether or not we have the ability, credibility, and necessary information to advise on this matter. Or put in another way, based on my ability, credibility, and information, what can I actually advise on? How much can I actually say? Reflecting on myself, I have some knowledge and experience in building relationships, I've studied relationships and decision making from ancient philosophers, and my friend trusts me. However, I don't have the necessary information to advise on whether or not she should divorce. I've only ever heard her side of the story. I have never talked to her husband, her parents, or his parents (yes, their parents are important people in this decision as they will get affected greatly). Therefore, I can only provide suggestions on how to make the decision, but I cannot push her towards a "yes" or a "no". There is important worldly wisdom here. If we push them towards a certain decision, what if they listen to us and later regret it? They'll think back to how we pushed them, and resentment may arise. Thus, for someone else's big decisions, it's usually not a good idea to push them towards any decision. Our role is to support in whatever way appropriate, but ultimately, they should be in the driver's seat and be willing to take full responsibility for their decision. From another perspective, whenever we are mediating a conflict, it's necessary to hear both sides of the story from both people. For example, when we listen to the wife, it sounds like the husband is terrible. Then we listen to the husband, and it sounds like the wife is terrible. We then have to weigh and filter both sides to try to get an accurate understanding of the situation. This also requires a lot of time and trust from all parties, which we may or may not have. From a third perspective, even if we patiently listen to them explain the situation and their feelings, can they really explain that clearly? Do they themselves truly know themselves deeply? Do they truly know why they want to make this decision? Are they clear on all the factors involved in this decision? It's one situation if they already have a decision in mind, explain their thought process to us, and ask us to check if there are any problems. It's a different situation if they just ask a big open question, "Should I divorce?". When they ask that big open question, we know that they themselves probably have not done the internal reflection and information gathering necessary to make that decision, and that process takes time, so we certainly shouldn't be advocating for a "yes" or "no" at this stage. Based on all of this, I told my friend, "This is a very big and complex decision that will require a lot of introspection on your part to make properly. So today, I'm just going to share my thoughts on how you can make this decision effectively. Of course, my thoughts shouldn't be just my thoughts, they should be based on the ancient teachings that we often discuss. Otherwise, please correct me." On a related note, if we are the person seeking advice, it's often better to ask "How should I think about making this decision?" as opposed to asking "Should I make this decision?". This is also worldly wisdom. If we ask someone for advice on a situation, and they passionately advise us towards doing it, but later we decided to not follow their advice, then they might feel hurt or feel that we don't trust them. Of course, it's also very important that we ask someone who is wise, trustworthy, and an expert on the subject matter; Otherwise, we are simply asking for trouble. 2: Meditate On Your Intentions Image Source: ChatGPT The first piece of advice I gave was this: "The word 'divorce' has a negative connotation to it. I know you probably worry that it's bad to get a divorce. I know you value compassion. But remember that whether an action is good or bad, and whether the karma we receive in the future is good or bad, depends not on the action, but rather on the intention. We often talk about that story from Liao Fan's Four Lessons , where some people asked a wise monk about the standard for good and bad. Some people said, 'Loving and respecting others is good,' and the monk said 'Not necessarily." Some people said 'Hitting and scolding others is bad.' The monk said 'Not necessarily.' It depends on the intention. If we are nice to others because we want to benefit from the relationship, then that's selfishness, and that's morally bad. If we hit and scold others because they have a big fault and stubborn personality, and they need strict punishment to correct themselves, then that is having their best interest at heart, and that is goodness. It's the same with this decision about divorce. Next, when it comes to having others' best intentions in mind, we also need to consider the bigger group and the long-term. Liao Fan's Four Lessons says, 'Don't think about just the present action, but also about unintended side effects. Don't think about just the immediate effects, but also about the long-term effects. Don't think just about one person, but about the whole world." You and him are the drivers for this decision. However, your parents are also important stakeholders who will get affected. Parents always want the best for their children. In the role of a child, it's important to ease our parents' worries. Otherwise, we'll create conflict with our parents, and that will haunt our conscience. That means we need to patiently communicate with our parents about this decision and not rush to make the decision if our parents aren't ready to accept our decision yet. Once we get our parents' support, we will have a strong moral force supporting us, giving us confidence and ease of mind. Thirdly, intentions are often a mix of good and bad, so Liao Fan's Four Lessons also emphasizes pure intentions. It tells us to ' clean our hearts from the small hidden corners '. We might think we are doing something for the good of others, but deep down, do we still have selfishness mixed in? Is there still a bit of us that is doing this because we really want to gain some sort of benefit for ourselves? Or to avoid trouble and inconvenience for ourselves? If there are still shadows of selfishness in our hearts, then we won't have an easy conscience, and we won't be able to confidently stand by our decision when others challenge us. A great role model is Kazuo Inamori, who is considered a business sage in Japan. He had great business success in his career and advocated the teachings of Liao Fan's Four Lessons . He also practiced them of course. When he entered the telecom industry, he meditated on his intentions. He didn't do it because he wanted to earn more profits. It's because at the time, there was only one telecom provider, so they could charge unreasonably high prices. Telecom is a necessary service for all the people, and he wanted to help reduce their burden. That's why he entered the telecom business and was very successful. But he didn't make that decision until he was sure that his intention was pure. Age 65, he decided to retire and become a monk, seeking a spiritual path. But when he was 77, the Japanese government asked him to come back to the ordinary world and save the national airline, Japan Airlines. Again, he meditated for months on his intentions. Was there any desire for self-gain? To avoid hassles and trouble? He washed away those selfish intentions. He focused on what's best for all the people. Air travel is a necessary service to the nation. If Japan Airlines goes bankrupt, it would create great trouble for the country, and it would cause the people to lose confidence in their nation. He has the background and expertise to help, so he cannot turn a blind eye and still have an easy conscience. Thus, he left the temple and accepted the role as President of Japan Airlines when it already filed for bankruptcy protection. Within two years, he turned the company around, and it was re-listed onto the Tokyo Stock Exchange. Ultimately, what happens in the future depends on our intentions. The more pure and good our intention, the better the future we will attract and manifest. That's why Inamori spent so long meditating on and purifying his intentions. Whether or not you divorce is not the big matter. The big matter is the strength and purity of your intention." My friend asked how she should meditate on her intention. I replied: "I'm not an expert on this either, but in my experience, it's about cultivating a mind of tranquility and stillness. The mind is more rational and makes better decisions when it is calm and tranquil, so we want to make sure we are in a state of calm and tranquility before thinking about a decision. To give an analogy, the mind is like a mirror. Emotions like desire, worry, fear, annoyance, etc. are like dust. When the mirror is covered with dust, it cannot reflect the situation clearly. If we cannot see the situation clearly, then how can we make a good decision? Calming the mind is like cleaning off that dust. Once the mind is tranquil, we can see the situation clearly, and then the answer becomes obvious. Image Source: Unsplash In terms of how to calm the mind and attain a state of tranquility, each person can find what works for them. Some people like to sit down, close their eyes, and meditate. Others like to walk in nature, or run, or knit. Personally, I do Buddha-name chanting where I chant 'Amitabha' like a mantra. If I need to make a big decision, I might try to do some 2-hour meditation sessions or however long I need to attain a state of tranquility. At the beginning, it feels like my mind is a wild horse. It keeps running in different directions with all these wandering thoughts. But if I persist, eventually, the mind calms down and becomes quiet, and I feel like my mind is super clear. In this state, it's easier to have realizations. You don't have to intentionally think about or analyze the answer. When we attain an elevated state of mind, the answer seems to naturally come to us. Another method is loving-kindness meditation. A pure mind (free from selfishness) is naturally compassionate. Kindness is innate in all of us. When we make a decision from a purely kind heart, it is true goodness. There are lots of guided loving-kindness meditations on the internet, but basically, you can close your eyes and visualize someone that you love dearly. Maybe it's your mom, or your dog, someone who you want nothing but the best for. Then imagine that loving energy all around you, filling every cell in your body. When you feel the love and warmth of that energy, think about that decision. What's the natural answer that comes to mind? When an answer comes to me, I try to be cautious. I don't want to suddenly get too excited. I will check with other wise people and ask them to look for holes in my thinking. I might do some more meditation sessions as well. If after all of that, I'm still confident about my decision, then I will make it." 3: Affected Parties My friend asked, "So from the perspective of filial piety, should I just listen to my parents here?" I replied: "You and him are the drivers of the decision. The responsibility for the decision lies with you two. However, we also have to consider affected parties and give them appropriate involvement and participation in the decision. Both your parents are affected, so it's important to consult them." My friend said that she talked about this with her parents before, and they want her to stay in the marriage, but her parents don't know everything. At the same time, she also doesn't want to say too much because she doesn't want them to worry unnecessarily. I replied: "It's great that you don't want your parents to worry unnecessarily. But we have to judge each situation to determine what's better. If it were a smaller decision, then maybe it's fine to not tell them all the details. But since this is a very big decision, you should try to patiently and sincerely communicate with your parents. After all, your parents want the best for you, but they don't have the credentials to advise you if they don't even understand the situation fully. If you listen to them just because 'a good child is supposed to listen to parents', but you didn't communicate with them sincerely, then that isn't truly being a good child, and you might create trouble and resentment in the future. Of course, before you communicate with them, it's important that you meditate on your intentions first so that you can bring a calm energy to the conversation. Energy is contagious. If you're all anxious and worried about it, they'll catch that energy and become worried as well. But if you are calm and confident about it, then they'll catch that energy too." 4: Weighing Factors, Other Options, and Risk Mitigation One more point is that we can list all the decision-making factors on a piece of paper and give them weights. Image Source: Unsplash For example, you might have factors like My goals His goals My willingness to change His willingness to change His trustworthiness My parents' opinions His parents' opinions Practical factors When you meditate on your intentions and cultivate a mind of tranquility and compassion, you might have some realizations about what factors to consider in the decision and what weight to give each factor. Maybe it's just one or two factors that matter the most. Maybe it's a mixture of multiple factors. Having this written down helps to give us a clear and well-rounded picture of the decision. It's also important to consider the flexibility of each factor. For example, if your parents' opinion right now is for you to stay in the marriage, but you haven't communicated sincerely with them yet, then you should try and change that first. Or if his goals don't align with yours, but you haven't tried to align them yet, you can try that first. We should also consider the pros and cons of each decision and think about how big they are and if the risks can be mitigated. For example, if you choose to divorce, then there's the risk of creating resentment. How big of a deal is it? If big, how can you mitigate it? Well, if we meditate on our intentions beforehand, it'll increase the chances that they know we have their best intentions at heart. Or if you choose to stay in the marriage, there's the risk that he continues to do the things that made you want to divorce before. Maybe you can mitigate that by having couple counseling or therapy. We shouldn't think of decisions as just yes or no; oftentimes, there are other options if we shift from a win-lose mindset to a win-win mindset. Conclusion We will probably all encounter situations in life where someone asks us for advice on a big decision. When this happens, it's important for us to have wisdom, to weigh our abilities, to know what's appropriate to say, and to prevent unintended harm. I don't have perfect wisdom, so what I share is just for consideration. Oftentimes, it's better to advise on how to think about the decision as opposed to pushing for a certain decision. As for the decision making process, it's important to purify our intentions, involve the affected parties, weigh the relevant factors, consider unexplored options, and mitigate the risks wherever possible. Weekly Wisdom #369
- Life Lessons From The Boy And The Heron
I recently watched The Boy and the Heron by Hayao Miyazaki, which is the fifth-grossing Japanese film of all time and won the Golden Globe Award for Best Animated Feature Film. But aside from the beautiful animation and rich story, the film gave me a lot of food for thought and life lessons, which is what I want to share in this article. Image Source Warning: There will be spoilers, but I will not explain the plot of the story ( Wikipedia already did that). It's certainly helpful to watch the movie before reading this article, but it's not necessary as I will explain any required context. Also, any movie lines I quote are from my memory since I watched this in theatre, so the wording may not be exactly right, but the message should be the same. 1: A peaceful world starts with my peaceful heart. Near the end of the movie, the main character, Mahito Maki, had the choice to inherit and continue the magical world created by his granduncle. The foundation of this world is a tower of small stones created by the granduncle. But his tower was about to collapse soon, and only someone of his bloodline could inherit this world by creating a new tower with new stones. Hence, the uncle collected some stones and asked Mahito to build a new tower. Mahito looked at the stones and sensed that there was malice in these stones, so he refused. Indeed, before meeting his granduncle, who lived at the top or "heaven" layer of this magical world, he experienced the lower levels of this world (one of the living beings there called it "hell"), where he witnessed a lot of suffering. I think it's very understandable that he didn't want to be responsible for a world that causes suffering to so many living beings. Later, even closer to the end of the movie, Mahito meets his granduncle once more. This time, his tower is really about to collapse, meaning the whole magical world was about to collapse. The granduncle said, "I found some pure stones without any malice in them. Please, build your tower and continue this world." This time, Mahito said, " I can't. The stones may not have malice, but I still have malice inside me. " While saying this, he pointed to a scar at the side of his head. For context, Mahito is a young boy living in a time of war, and he lost his mother in a factory fire. When he heard the news, he immediately ran to the factory to try to save his mother, but he was unsuccessful, and this traumatized him. His father then remarried his mother's younger sister (because the sister would more likely care for Mahito than an outsider, and also to keep the family wealth in the same family) and moved to the countryside (because it's safer there during the war and because they have a big residence there). Mahito then had to deal with trying to accept his new stepmother, which is really hard since he really misses his original mother. He then goes to school, but he is different from everyone because he comes from the city, and his family is much richer than the village kids. His classmates are prejudiced towards him and bully him, and he ends up fighting with them. On his way home, he picks up a stone and hits the side of his head with it, creating a big wound. As a result, his father thinks that the students attacked him and tells him to rest at home instead of going to school. From all of this, we can see that Mahito is a young kid who went through a lot of suffering, and in his pain, he also did violent things such as fighting with other kids and injuring himself. He sees the evil inside of him, and he understands that his heart will taint the stones, so that even if the stones are pure, once he uses them, they will become impure, and the world he creates will still have suffering. One aspect of Miyazaki films is the purity of young children. In this sense, Mahito doesn't want to cause suffering to others, so he refuses to inherit and continue his uncle's magical world. This reminds me of a Buddhist teaching: "A peaceful world starts with my peaceful heart." So often, people try to achieve peace through methods, whether it be politics, economics, technology, military, etc. But whether or not these methods have a positive or negative effect depends on the intention (or "heart") behind them. To give a simple example, the western world heavily emphasizes communication. Communication is a method, not an attitude or intention. If we communicate with the intention to defeat others in an argument, then our bad intentions will taint our communication skills, and our strong communication skills would just create more conflict. If we have good intentions but lack communication skills, then at least the results won't be harmful, but the effect might still be lacking. Thus, we need both good intentions and good methods to achieve good results. However, having good intentions is the most fundamental and should come first. 2: Love and morality starts with those closest to us When the granduncle heard Mahito's refusal, he said, " Why would you want to go back to Earth? That world will burn in flames soon! " Clearly, the granduncle is also aware of the war situation on Earth, and he probably also experienced a lot of suffering during his time on Earth, which is why he wanted to create his own, better world. Unfortunately, the stones that helped him create his world are evil. He lives in a heavenly area, but the living beings below suffer. Perhaps that's also why he wanted a new successor who could better the world he created. Mahito replied, " Yes, but there is goodness there too. I've learned how to make friends. And I can learn to love others. I need to go back. " More context: There is a magical heron or manbird that led Mahito into this world to find his stepmother and bring her back to Earth. Originally, he didn't trust this heron, but throughout their journey in the magical world, they gradually became friends. He also met the younger versions of his mother and a servant maid in his house, and they all helped him along his journey. Thus, his heart gained more love and gratitude, and he naturally didn't want to abandon his family on Earth, which is where he belongs. This reminds me of a Confucian teaching from The Classic of Filial Piety : "To love others yet not love one's parents violates morality." If he says that he has a loving heart because he wants to create a world without suffering, but in doing so, he abandons his family on Earth without saying a word, causing his dad and stepmother to grieve over the loss of their child, wouldn't that be rather contradictory? How can you truly have a loving and noble heart when you cause suffering to the people closest to you, to the people who love you the most, to the people you received the most kindness from? I think if Mahito really made the choice to inherit the magical world, thus never being able to leave and see his family again, he would probably have an uneasy conscience and regret his choice. Similarly, I used to put work and friends above family, and as a result, family conflict was always a nagging burden at the back of my mind, leading to an uneasy conscience. Once I learned Confucianism, I prioritized family first, and my conscience became at ease. 3: Attitude towards problems Both Mahito and his granduncle agree that Earth is a terrible place with a lot of suffering. His granduncle chose to abandon Earth and try to create a better world. Mahito, on the other hand, chose to accept Earth the way it is, let go of blame and resentment, and focus on the possibility for goodness and improvement in the world, starting with his own kind heart. Just like how the kindness of others changed him, if he can spread this kindness, he can definitely make his world better. The original Japanese title of this film translates roughly to " What kind of life do you want to live? " or " How do you wish to live your life? ". Mahito's choice to return to Earth really made me think. Suffering is a fact of life. The world is full of problems. So how will you choose to deal with this fact? I think Miyazaki really wanted the audience to ponder this question. This made me think of a quote from Captain Jack Sparrow: "The problem isn't the problem. The problem is your attitude towards the problem." When we see problems in the world, in our organization, in our group, in our family, do we simply blame others and stop there? Or do we take initiative and responsibility to improve the situation for everyone's benefit? The latter is what Mahito chose. 4: The importance of life education A big question I had after watching the movie was, " Why was Mahito able to change from a miserable young boy, who felt helpless and upset at the world, to a noble young man who could take initiative and responsibility to live in and improve a world of suffering? " The answer lies in a scene near the beginning of the movie. When Mahito and his father moved to the countryside residence, his stepmother was already pregnant. The servant maids told him many times to go see his stepmother, but he refused because he still didn't accept her as his new mother. After being told many times, he finally went, but even in that encounter, he still refused to embrace her. Later, he saw his stepmother walking into a nearby forest, which should seem very strange because his stepmother was really weak and sick from being pregnant, so why would she walk into a forest? The scene looked like she was possessed. Despite seeing this, Mahito didn't care. He just continued on with his day. He went to his room and accidentally found a book left to him by his late mother. The name of this book is also the name of the movie in Japanese: " What kind of life do you want to live? " Image Source This is actually a real book, and the director Miyazaki said this book had a big impact on his life when he was a young boy. The movie didn't explain the content of the book, it just showed that Mahito read the book all day and had tears in his eyes afterwards. By evening, he had finished the book, and the housemaids were all concerned that they couldn't find the stepmother, so they were all outside searching for her and shouting her name. When Mahito heard the maids outside searching for his stepmother, he stood up, ran out the room, and told everyone that he is also going to look for his stepmother. In other words, this book really changed his attitude towards life, which then changed his destiny. If he hadn't read this book, then perhaps he would have turned out like his granduncle, or worse. This really makes me think about the importance of life education. Nowadays, our education system teaches us knowledge and skills, like language, math, science, history, geography, etc. But we don’t receive formal education on how to live a good life, on how to have good relationships, on how to make wise decisions. Some people are fortunate to have wise parents or mentors to help on this front. But we can't rely on others to save us. We have to take responsibility for our life and do this learning in our own time, which is why I spend my free time learning ancient philosophies such as Stoicism, Confucianism, Daoism, and Buddhism. What I learned in school helped me get a job and make a living, but what I learned from ancient philosophy enabled me to upgrade my thinking and to gain wisdom, happiness, and peace of mind. 5: Sincere kindness transforms people The English title of this movie is The Boy and the Heron , and that's because aside from Mahito, the other leading character of this movie is a man-bird magical heron. It is this heron that lures Mahito into the magical world and accompanies him on his journey. At the beginning of the movie, Mahito was very suspicious towards the heron and even made a bow and arrow to shoot the heron. He was able to shoot an arrow into the heron's beak, which reverted the heron into a man-bird form, thereby preventing him from flying. Since he couldn't fly away, he had no choice but to accompany Mahito. Later, they encountered an area guarded by man-eating parakeets. The heron told him that if he wants to pass this area, he needs the heron to create a distraction to lure away the parakeets. In order for that to happen, Mahito needs to fill the hole in his beak, which will allow him to fly again. Mahito said, "If I fill in the hole in your beak, how do I know you won't just fly away and abandon me?" The heron said, " You can't know. It's your choice. " Mahito then took a tree branch and started carving a small cylinder to fill in the hole. He then put it in the heron's beak. The heron reverted to its bird form and excitedly said, " Haha! I can fly again. I'm outta here! So long! " As the heron started flapping his swings, he reverted back to his bird-man form. It turns out the cylinder was a bit too big and didn't fully fit in the hole. The movie then shows Mahito carving the cylinder a bit more, with the man-bird looking ashamed and embarrassed. Mahito then puts the cylinder into the beak again, this time fitting properly. The heron said, " Why did you continue to help me even after I betrayed you? " Mahito didn't reply. This scene also made me think a lot. The first time Mahito helped the heron makes logical sense. If he refuses to help the heron, he has no chance of advancing on his journey, so he has nothing to lose by helping the heron. But after he learned that the heron intended to abandon him, why would he continue to help the heron? Mahito didn't say, so it's up to us to speculate. Perhaps Miyazaki wanted to show the innate goodness of children and encourage people to return to the innate goodness that all of us had when we were children. In this case, I think Mahito didn't really need a logical reason to continue helping the heron. He did it purely out of kindness. He had no demands or expectations in return. If he can't advance in his journey, then at least by helping the heron, the heron wouldn't be stuck with him. It is this kind of selfless, sincere kindness that moves and changes people. That's what makes people ashamed of themselves and become motivated to improve their moral character, which was what happened to the heron. Later on in the movie, Mahito gets caught by the parakeets, and the heron actually infiltrates their layer to save Mahito. When Mahito told his granduncle that he made friends such as the heron, the heron was surprised to hear Mahito calling him a friend. At the end of the movie, the heron even said to Mahito, " Goodbye, friend. " Thus, if we have a negative relationship with someone, it doesn't have to stay that way. We can change the relationship through sincere kindness. When we continue to show kindness to others in spite of their unkindness, and without expecting anything in return, eventually, their sense of shame will arise, and they will change for the better. That can change a terrible relationship to an extremely great one, as was the case with Mahito and the heron. 6: Despicable people have lamentable circumstances In the lower levels of the granduncle's magical world, Mahito encounters a person named Kiriko, who takes care of cute little bubble-like spirits called Warawara. When these Warawara mature enough, they will float up into the sky and seek birth on Earth. One night, Mahito sees many Warawara floating up into the sky. Kiriko comes out and says with tears in her eyes that the Warawara have finally grown up, and that this event happens very rarely. It's kind of like a parent crying out of happiness when seeing their child all grown up and leaving the house. Suddenly, a swarm of pelicans come and start eating the defenseless Warawara. Kiriko is angered at the despicable behavior of the pelicans, but there's nothing she or Mahito can do. Then another person in a small boat on the lake below starts shooting fireballs into the air, thereby burning the pelicans and Warawara. The pelicans then flee, and the remaining Warawara are able to complete their journey to Earth. Later that night, Mahito hears a sound outside the house. He goes out and finds a heavily burnt and wounded pelican. The pelican says, " I'm in so much pain. Please, just kill me and end my suffering. " Mahito replied, " It's your fault for preying on the Warawara. " The pelican said, " We were brought here, but there's nothing for us to eat. There's no fish in the water for us to catch, so our tribe flies higher and higher in hopes of escaping this world, but we can't. When we see the Warawara, we can finally eat something, but then we get burned by fireballs. Our choices are either starve to death or get burned to death. It's truly hell. " After saying this, the pelican died. Mahito felt sorrow for the pelican and decided to bury it. This scene reminded me of something my mentor often says: "If one can be a good person, who would want to be a bad person? If one can be liked by others, who would want to be disliked by others?" In other words, everyone is just doing their best to do what they think is right. No one is trying to be wrong or illogical or disliked on purpose. Thus, when we judge others to be wrong, illogical, or despicable, we are using our own standards to judge our limited understanding of them. If we truly understand others, we would be much more compassionate towards them. It's a good reminder for us to try to be more compassionate and understanding towards others, especially the people that we find annoying or difficult to understand. Conclusion I really enjoyed watching The Boy and Heron , not just because of the beautiful animations and rich story, but also because of the many deep life lessons embedded throughout. These are just my reflections and thoughts, and I'm sure there are many things I missed. If you have any other life lessons you took away from the film, I'd love to hear about them. Weekly Wisdom #287
- Wise Principles For Great Decisions
"The quality of your life ultimately depends on the quality of your decisions." —Ray Dalio, Billionaire investor and author of Principles We all work hard every day to create a better life for ourselves. But if we make poor decisions, then no matter how hard we work, our life will be miserable. Thus, we all need to learn how to make excellent decisions. Icon Sources: 1 , 2 What is the key to making good decisions? Wisdom. Wisdom to our happiness is like eyes to our body. If we lack wisdom, we may be working extremely hard but going in the wrong direction, and we wouldn't even know it. After a while, we're exhausted, on the wrong road, and didn't achieve what we hoped. Isn't that just terribly unfortunate and tragic? Thus, wisdom is something we cannot neglect and must proactively learn. Ray Dalio gave many wise principles for making great decisions in his book, Principles , but he also encouraged readers to find principles of our own. It's been a few years since I read his book, and I have indeed found more wise principles for making great decisions. In case you are curious, the principles that Ray Dalio gave in his book are Overcome your ego and blind spots Seek out credible and open-minded people to discuss with Remember the 80/20 Rule Navigate levels of a decision Make decisions as expected-value calculations Use principles to systematize decisions I won't elaborate on them in this article because I've already done so in my book summary article . In this article, I want to share six more principles for making wise decisions. Focus on the side effects not just the intended effect, on the long-term not just the short-term, on the bigger group not just one person It's never just option A or option B. You can find options C, D, E. Don't think there's just one factor to the problem. Consider all the factors and their relationships. There is rarely ever a perfect decision When making decisions with others, factor in their feelings Make decisions from a calm and pure mind These are by no means an exhaustive list, but knowing them could help you avoid a lot of unnecessary suffering due to bad decisions. 1: Focus on the side effects, long-term, and bigger group This comes from the book Liao Fan's Four Lessons , which said: "Do not just consider the present action, but also consider its side effects. Do not just consider immediate effects, but also consider the long-term effects. Do not just consider the effects on one person, but also consider the effects on the greater whole." Icon Sources: 1 , 2 , 3 Often, when people make decisions, they only focus on their desired outcome, and they forget about side effects (long-term effects and broader effects on others are both examples of side effects). This leads to narrow thinking that prevents us from seeing the bigger picture, resulting in poor decision making. For example, a friend of mine started working at a summer camp, and at the beginning, she told me she was really tired and overworked, and that the food there was too spicy for her, which upset her stomach and gave her stomachaches. Eventually she started feeling sick. I told her, " You should communicate these problems early with the school so that they can make adjustments accordingly. If they have enough people there, you don't have to force yourself to stay there the whole summer, right? " She replied, "But I don't want to be a bother to them. Plus, I promised that I would work here for the summer." In her mind, she thinks she is being considerate by not making requests to accommodate her individual needs, and that she is being trustworthy by trying to stay there the whole summer. But her kind intentions lack wisdom. First, thinking long-term : she might be able to get by in the short-term, but if this accumulates and she gets really sick, the school would end up having to take care of her in addition to the kids, which is giving them more burden. Or she might have to leave the school to go to the hospital or return home. Then it would be hard for the school to find a replacement teacher on such a short notice. The school would get upset at her for not telling them about her problems early on so that they could solve it earlier. Second, thinking for the broader group : if she gets sick, she might make others sick too. Or if she is exhausted, she might do her work sloppily, which then adds burden to other people and annoys them. After all, the school probably interprets the promise as having a healthy productive employee working there the whole summer, not a sick and tired person. Also, if the food is too spicy for her, it's possible that other people feel the same way, and if she spoke up about it, others might benefit too. Third, thinking about unintended side effects : if word gets out that she is very overworked and even got sick from working at that school, then people might criticize this school for not taking care of its staff, and people would not want to send their kids to this school in the future. Even worse is if the school gets blamed for abusing their employees when in fact she was the one hiding her symptoms. Then the school would be very angry at her. From this example, we see how sometimes, we think we are doing good because we have a good intention, but our good intentions are too narrow-minded and short-sighted, resulting in long-term harm and negative side effects. Unfortunately, it's quite common to see people chase short-term gains at the cost of long-term sustainability, or do things without considering the impact on others or the potential side effects. Thus, they bring suffering upon themselves and others in the future. A wise person would think about the long-term, the broader group, and the unintended side effects. 2: It's never just option A or option B. You can find options C, D, E. Oftentimes, we think there are only two options. But we can use our creativity to think of other options. The key is to focus on the goal rather than on the method. It's just like traveling through a city; there are always multiple paths we can take to get from one place to another. As long as we focus on the destination and be attached to a certain route, we can always find other routes. Image Source For example, I've recently been helping a couple English teachers with their classes. One piece of feedback they gave me was, " You give us lots of great ideas, but these all take time to lesson plan. We are so busy just trying to get the lesson done week to week, we don't have enough time to plan such an ideal lesson according to your standards. " It just so happened that one of the teachers had to take a break from teaching for a month, and the school asked me to cover her class. I said since I am covering her class anyway, I could take the other teacher's class too and just merge them into one class. That would give the other teacher a month off to lesson plan. After teaching the merged class a few times, I told them, " It's definitely feasible to teach all the students in one class. The level difference is not that big of a problem. If you two merge the classes into one, then you could take turns teaching the class one semester at a time. This way, while one person is teaching, the other teacher can plan all the lessons for the next semester. This would free up a LOT of time for both of you. " My suggestion ended up becoming a big discussion topic, and we spent hours talking about the pros, cons, and feasibility of it. Essentially, they were worried about the extra time it would take to grade homework for the merged class, as well as the difficulty of teaching students of mixed levels. We spent so many hours debating about whether to merge the classes or to keep them split, but later, I thought about the original goal, which is to give them more time to lesson plan, so I thought of another option. I told them, " Since our goal is to give you guys more time to lesson plan, then another option is for you guys to keep teaching your separate classes, but you both do semesters. Right now you both teach non-stop for most of the year, so you never have a break to really calm down, reflect on how you're doing, and plan for the future. If you taught for a few months, then took a two-week break, that would help you a lot. This option has a lot of benefits with nearly no downsides. " We also discussed many mitigation methods, such as having stronger students tutor weaker students outside of class time to mitigate the level difference problem, and not giving individual homework feedback to every student to mitigate the workload problem. When we are focused on the goal and not the method, we can always think of extra options. 3: Consider all the factors to a goal and their relationships Sometimes, when we are making a decision, we only see one factor, and we forget the possibility that other factors could be involved, or that one decision impacts multiple factors at once. To continue the example above, the two teachers were concerned that merging the classes would increase the homework grading required, which would reduce their free time to complete other responsibilities. If you look at the decision's impact on just this one factor (homework grading), then yes, this is true. But we have to remember that there are other factors, and we have to look at the overall effect taking into account all factors. I replied, " Yes it is true that you will have more students, which means more homework to grade. But you shouldn't forget that by having a merged class, you have a whole semester off to plan your lessons. That means when you do teach, you will spend a lot less time on lesson planning. You have to factor that in. So the main question is: Is the time you free up in lesson planning more than the extra time needed to grade homework for more students? This would be something you might have to experiment with to find out." As we discussed more, we realized that our ultimate goal is not just to save teachers time, it's to increase teaching quality. In that case, spending extra time grading students' homework actually increases teaching quality, which means we should do it. Plus, there are many other factors we should discuss about, such as having a teacher development plan, making tailored learning plans for students, and providing extra help outside of class time. We shouldn't be tunnel-visioned on one factor and forget about the other factors. 4: There is rarely ever a perfect decision Every option has their pros and cons, and every reward has its costs. We have to consider and weigh all the different factors and all their pros and cons and make the best tradeoff. We should also consider which cons can be mitigated and how easily they can be mitigated. Sometimes, we sink into analysis paralysis, where we just keep analyzing options excessively. One reason is because we are looking for an obvious best choice. But oftentimes, there is no obvious best choice, let alone a perfect choice. If the analysis starts to go in circles, then it might be better to just make a decision. If you feel like none of the options are good, then one way to reframe the idea of " I want to make the best decision " is to think of it as " I want to make the least worst decision. " And remember: not making a decision is also a decision, and inaction has its pros and cons as well. Moreover, we can always try a decision for a short time, gather new information, and then re-evaluate. It's just like if you are not sure a certain vegetable would taste good or not, you can buy a little bit to try first. If it turns out to be good, then buy more later. In the case of the English teachers, one of the teachers decided to try teaching the big class for a few weeks to see how it goes. If she finds it manageable, then the other teacher could try it too. If not, then we can discuss why, and if it really isn't suitable, we can just return to two classes as before. 5: When making decisions with others, factor in their feelings As a very logic-driven person, I sometimes neglect others' feelings. But I ought to remember that the success of a decision is not just on how logical the decision is, but largely on the people who carry out the decision. Even if a decision is logically the best, if the people who have to carry it out don't support it, then they won't try their best. When they don't try their best, the decision will not be carried out fully, and when problems arise, the person will say, "See, I knew it. This decision was not a good idea." It became a self-fulfilling prophecy. If a decision wasn't logically the best, but the people really believed in it, then the people would work really hard to make it succeed and overcome all challenges. In other words: A logically good enough option with strong support from the people is better than the best logical option with weak support from the people. Hence, with those two teachers, I said, "Whether we merge the classes or not, it's most important that you guys feel happy with the decision. After all, you are the ones that have to carry out the decision. If you are unhappy, it will definitely reflect in your teaching quality." Ultimately, when making decisions with others, it's very important to get other people's buy-in as much as possible. Obviously, in a large group, it might be impossible to get everyone's buy-in or to reach a consensus, but we should still do our best to show that we've listened to every perspective and thought about them thoroughly before making the decision. This helps everyone feel heard and respected, which would improve their acceptance of the final decision. 6: Make decisions from a calm and pure mind. This final principle is the most important one. If we want to use any of the principles mentioned above, we need to first have a calm and pure mind, free from negative emotions and biases . Think about it: people who make bad decisions usually do so from an agitated or muddled state of mind. Thus, before we make a decision, we should first ask: "How is my state of mind right now? Is it calm, considerate, and peaceful? Or is it agitated, impatient, unhappy?" The wise sages of the past taught that we all have innate wisdom, which arises from a calm and pure mind. In other words, even if we never learned the principles for decision-making mentioned earlier, if our mind was calm and pure enough, we would naturally make wise decisions that are in accordance with the aforementioned principles. What blocks our innate wisdom? There's a Chinese idiom that says, "Desire makes wisdom muddled. Self-interest makes wisdom dizzy." (Original Text: 欲令智迷,利令智昏) In other words, it is selfish desire. Think about it, why do people make stupid decisions? Because their desire to get a certain benefit is too strong, such that they can't think about long-term effects, broader effects, other options, or other people's feelings. The stronger the selfish desire, the more tainted the mind becomes, and the deeper our wisdom gets buried. If we instead dim our self-interest and think for the greater long-term good, then we naturally end up benefiting ourselves and others. For example, when my friend said she didn't want to tell the school that she wasn't feeling well because she didn't want to cause trouble, was that coming from a calm and pure mind without any selfish desire? I would guess that there was ego involved, and the ego desires others to think good of them and is afraid of others thinking badly of them. If so, then her mind wasn't calm and pure, so the decision probably wouldn't be wise. Another example: when I recommended the option to merge the classes, was that purely to benefit them, or was there any selfish desire or ego involved? I would say it is purely to help them. I don't benefit at all from the decision because I won't even be there in the future. Later, when they resisted, was there ego involved when I argued for its benefits? Perhaps I didn't want to be viewed as dumb for recommending a bad decision. When I considered this possibility, I immediately reminded myself to filter through the decision making principles to ensure that this was a wise decision and not one tainted by selfish desire. All humans have a strong ego, so we have to be very cautious and not deceive ourselves when inspecting our mind and intentions. Using our logical mind to think about side effects, other options, other people's feelings, and other decision-making principles can help us to tame our selfish desires. But doing other activities to calm and purify our minds can help too, such as meditation, going for a calming walk, even taking a shower. It's not a coincidence that people get eureka moments in the shower…it's because their mind was really calm and pure in that moment, so a spark of wisdom came out. There's an old Zen saying that goes, "You should meditate for 20 minutes a day. Unless you're too busy, then you should meditate for an hour." When I first heard this, I didn't understand. If I'm too busy to meditate for 20 minutes, why are you telling me to meditate for an hour? That would just make me even more stressed and more short on time. Later, I started to understand. If our mind is so agitated from being so busy all the time, then our effectiveness in everything that we do would be low, and that would result in a negative spiral. It's like trying to cut a tree with a dull ax; it's tiring and slow. Sharpening the ax is analogous to purifying the mind. If we spent some time to meditate or do any activity that really helps to calm the mind down, then we would approach everything with more wisdom. One wise decision would save endless headaches from a stupid decision. Thus, if we can cultivate a calm and pure mind every day, and we can maintain this state of mind longer and longer, then we will see all things with more wisdom, and our quality of life will surely become better and better. Conclusion There are only a few things that can drastically improve the quality of our lives, and one of them is wisdom, which helps us to make excellent decisions. (In case you're wondering what are some of those other things that drastically improve our lives, the ones that come to my mind are relationships , virtues , and health , which is why I spend a lot of time learning about these.) This article discussed six principles for making wise decisions. If you try them or have other wise decision making principles, I'd love to know. Thanks, and cheers to a wise life ahead! Weekly Wisdom #250
- Principles for Effective Advising, Criticism, and Recommendations
Do you ever feel like it’s so difficult to advise others to change? That we give such heartfelt suggestions, but they seem to be deaf, or they always have a counter-argument to everything we say? If this situation continues, eventually we just want to save our breath and give up on giving suggestions. But the problem is, these people are our family, friends, colleagues, or leaders. We still have to interact with them frequently, so if we don’t urge them to change, we’ll continue to have conflict and troubles with them. From another perspective, what is one of the best gifts that we can give others? What is one of the best ways to help others? Wouldn’t that be telling them how to fix a problem that they have in a way that they would be persuaded, which then changes their life for the better? Thus, we see how valuable it is to be able to advise others effectively. But the big question is: How? Image Source: ChaptGPT In this article, I will share some communication principles that I’ve learned over the years: Correct our own attitude and intentions. Be aware of and maintain our state of mind. Build trust. Don’t make people look bad in front of others. Set the stage. Pick a good setting and time. Be conservative. Be a problem-solver, not a problem-talker. Observe and adjust. Be patient. I believe that everyone has good intentions and is trying to do what they think is right. No one tries to create conflict or misery on purpose, and conflict arises because people have not learned communication principles. Or even if they have learned, they haven’t really practiced these principles and become proficient at practicing them…yet. Personally, I still have conflicts with people in daily life, and I’m still working on practicing these principles, but I have found that when I can follow these principles, communication becomes a lot smoother, and the feeling of understanding and warmth we get from good communication is so rewarding. I hope that sharing these principles will be helpful to others. 1: Correct our own thoughts. There’s a Chinese proverb that goes, “When you don’t get what you want, reflect on yourself.” Icon Source If we advise others, and they don’t respond in the way we hope, we shouldn’t think, “They’re just stubborn. They’re just arrogant. They’ll never understand. It’s no use trying to advise them.” That’s putting the blame on others, which is not only ineffective, it’s wrong. Nothing is ever 100% one person’s fault. Sure, their attitude might be a part of the problem, but focusing on their problem isn’t helpful because we cannot control others. Moreover, if someone else advised them, it’s totally possible that they would listen to that other person. In other words, we definitely have a part in the problem, and if we correct our part of the problem, it would naturally change how the other person responds to us. Therefore, when others don’t respond in the way we want, we need to reflect on how we should change, which would naturally change how they respond to us. In terms of how to correct ourselves, the book Liao Fan’s Four Lessons goes into great detail. The book teaches that we can correct ourselves from three levels: action, speech, and thoughts. The root (or the deepest level) is the level of thoughts. Our speech and actions arise from our thoughts, so the key is to correct our thoughts, which would then influence our feelings and the energy we give off, which then determines other people’s response towards us. We want to avoid thoughts of Opposition: “You are wrong and I am right; I need to win this argument.” Blame: “It’s your fault. Not mine.” Demands: “You have to listen to me. You have to change. You should apologize.” Stubbornness: “I’m not letting up no matter what.” Complaining: “I don’t like it when you do that. Why did you do that again? How many times do I have to tell you?” The energy we give is the energy we attract back. When we have the energy of opposition, we attract opposition back. When we have the energy of blame, we attract defensiveness in return. When we demand others to do something, we attract resistance. When we are stubborn, we bring out their stubbornness. When we complain about things, others naturally feel annoyed towards us. The list can go on and on. Instead, we need to cultivate good, proper, and effective thoughts: Responsibility: “I am responsible for my own feelings and results. If the other person doesn’t respond in the way I want, or if I get upset, I need to change myself, not them. When I change myself, I naturally change the way others respond to me.” Faith in human goodness: “Everyone is trying to do what they think is good, right, or acceptable. If they know something isn’t good but still do it, then they can’t control their bad habits, which was probably developed without their own conscious decision. Since it’s not a result of their conscious decision, they are a victim of misfortune. If I overly criticize them, they might lose faith in themselves and stoop even lower. If I encourage and affirm them, they will try to rise to meet those affirmations.” Understanding: “When I understand others, I wouldn’t be upset at them anymore. When others feel understood by me, then they’ll have the mental capacity to try to understand me.” Humility: “I can’t be 100% confident in any of my ideas. Every situation is infinitely complex with so many factors and perspectives, so I should be humble and conservative when communicating my suggestions.” Kindness: “My goal is to help them, not to vent emotions.” The greater good: “I will speak up because I am thinking for the long-term wellness of the bigger group, not just for any one person.” If we can take the time to organize and clean up our own thoughts and feelings first, then when we communicate, our speech and actions will naturally be good and proper. (On a related note, these thoughts and attitudes are very important as the receiver of criticism as well. Even if the criticizer is emotional and negative, if we can maintain our calm, humble, and kind energy, the conversation will still go in a good direction.) 2: Be aware of and maintain our state of mind. The first principle requires us to organize and correct our thoughts and intentions before communicating. Once it’s time to communicate, we have to maintain awareness of our state of mind and thoughts throughout the conversation. It’s important to maintain a calm, peaceful, rational, and kind state of mind. There is a Chinese saying that goes, “The first effort in cultivation is to overcome agitation and be able to calm the mind.” Icon Source Thoughts are habitual, so if we often have negative thoughts of opposition, blame, complaining, defensiveness, etc., then chances are, these thoughts and feelings might pop up during the conversation in response to things the other person said. We don’t have to fear it. We just have to use it as a trigger for us to bring up proper thoughts, like those of responsibility, kindness, and humility. As Liao Fan’s Four Lessons states: “When proper thoughts arise, improper thoughts naturally lose their power.” If we happen to get into a heated argument, then it’s helpful to take a break. We can say to the other person, "Can we talk about this later when we are both calmer?" or "I need to go to the bathroom" and then do some deep breathing. Most things are not so urgent that we have to talk about them right away, so it’s better to reconvene at a later time when everyone is in a better mood. We can also be tactful and humorous by bringing some sweets and saying, “Let’s sweeten our mouths before we continue”. 3: Build trust Whether or not the other person takes our advice is largely dependent on their level of trust towards us. Two people can give the same suggestion in the same way to the same person, but the result will differ depending on the level of trust between them. If we advise others and they don’t listen, we should first reflect on whether we’ve done our best to communicate in the best way possible and follow all the other communication principles. If the answer is no, then we can try to improve ourselves. If the answer is yes, then perhaps they just don’t trust us enough yet, in which case we need to spend some time and effort into building trust. Icon Source How can we build trust? There are many ways, but here are some major ones: Let them feel understood. Let them feel that you have their best intentions at heart. Walk your talk and set a good example. Get the support of other people whom they trust or care about. First, we have to make them feel that we truly understand them, their situation, and their feelings. That requires us to listen attentively and patiently, ask questions to check our understanding, and then report our understanding and ask them if our understanding is accurate and complete. If we don’t do this, then we don’t have the credentials to advise them, and they wouldn’t trust our advice. Second, we need to let them feel that we truly have their best intentions at heart. This goes back to principles one and two. If they think we are just complaining or venting, then they would naturally defend themselves and criticize back, so we need to maintain a calm and kind state of mind. We need to check that we understand them and what they want, affirm their good intentions, and then tell them we are on the same team. Moreover, we should be building the relationship and helping them in regular daily life without any ulterior motives. Every act of kindness and service we do for others is like accumulating trust dollars in that relationship account. In other words, whether or not they listen to us in that conversation depends largely on all the past effort we’ve put into the relationship. Third, if we are advising others to do something, it’s important that we walk our talk. For example, if we tell others to be more considerate, then we should reflect on ourselves: are we considerate towards others? If yes, then they’ll be more likely to take our advice. If not, then they might respond, “You’re not any better than me, what right do you have to criticize me?” This doesn’t mean we don’t advise them. It just means we shouldn’t be demanding. We could say, “I have this problem too, but I’m working on it, and I think you would benefit a lot too if you also worked on it. We could support each other.” Fourth, we can get the support of other people whom they trust or care about, especially if their trust level towards us is not very high (yet). For example, we might tell a family member to eat healthier, but they don’t listen. If we enlist the help of their doctor, they might be more receptive. Or let’s say we want to propose a new idea at the workplace. If it’s just our idea, the leader might not act immediately. But if we get the support of many people and then propose it to the leader, the leader would take it more seriously. 4: Don’t make people look bad in front of others. A rule of etiquette is that we should praise people publicly and criticize privately (with kindness, of course). Icon sources: 1, 2 Everyone has an ego, and the ego hates looking bad, especially in front of others. If we speak of someone’s faults in front of others, then that person’s ego might get very upset and resent us. When this happens, reason is thrown out the door, and they will become defensive and argue back. Some people have extra sensitive egos. We might think we’re just giving a suggestion, but the listener might interpret it as an attack, so we have to have awareness about the situation and other people’s egos. For example, let’s say I want to give a suggestion in a work meeting. I need to think about how I phrase the problem. If I say the problem is because of X, then I need to think about who is responsible for X, and whether if that person might feel like I’m indirectly criticizing him for not doing a good enough job at X. If I’m worried about it, I could talk to him privately beforehand and let him know that I have this idea and ask him for his thoughts on it. This is especially important if that person is our leader. We don’t want to accidentally create conflict with our leader. Another tactic is to say, “We are currently doing X well, but I had an idea that could make X even better.” Or if I’m advising a person in private, and I think that person has a sensitive ego, I could say, “I think you’re doing great at X, and I just had an idea that if you also did Y, it would be even better!” 5: Set the stage Aside from not making others look bad, we should set the stage by making others look good and feel good first. We shouldn’t just jump straight into the problem. To set the stage, we can affirm their contributions, efforts, and good intentions. We should also explain the context and relevant details so that everyone is on the same page about the issue. Then we can start talking about the problem and our recommendation. Icon Source Setting the stage is so very important. To give an analogy, imagine a top chef cooked a spectacular meal. However, the meal is served in a cheap take-out container at a run-down restaurant. When the customer sees the meal, would she appreciate it the same as if it were served on an elegant plate at a fancy restaurant? Similarly, we might have really good advice that would really benefit the other person or the group, but if we don’t set the stage effectively, it won’t leave a good impression on others. For example, I recently started doing counseling with a student at school. Before the first counseling session, I imagined that he would be nervous about why he has to do counseling with me. He might resist the idea that he has problems and not want to do counseling. Therefore, I can’t start the counseling session by saying, “The school wants me to do counseling with you because you have some problems, and I’m here to help.” Instead, what I did was first praise him on a lot of good things that he improved on recently. For example, he had a tantrum, but he was able to calm down after his homeroom teacher talked to him. I praised him on four things and gave him four pieces of candy. Then he felt a lot happier. I then said, “You are doing great, and the school asked me to be your support in addition to your homeroom teacher. That’s why we are doing counseling. We’ll chat once a week, but we can chat more if you want, and if that week there’s not much to chat about, that’s totally fine too.” He's been happy to attend counseling sessions and even looks forward to them. 6: Pick a good setting and time. This one is similar to setting the stage. To continue the analogy from before, if a world-class chef cooked a spectacular meal and served it to you, but you’re already stuffed, or you’re in the bathroom, would you want to eat it? Similarly, we could have very useful advice, but if the timing or setting is not suitable, we should wait. The Chinese philosopher Kun Lu (吕坤) gave seven inappropriate situations to criticize or scold others: Don't criticize them in public Don't criticize them if they already feel remorse Don't criticize before sleep time Don’t criticize before or during meals Don't criticize when they are feeling very joyous Don't criticize if they are feeling depressed Don't criticize when they are ill I would add one more: Don't criticize or advise when they are clearly busy or rushed for time. We should wait for a time or schedule a time when they are calm, in a good mood, and have the time to listen and discuss. Icon Sources: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 For example, one staff meeting, I had many suggestions to talk about, and that requires a lot of time for discussion. The meeting happened near the end of the day, when everyone was tired and wanted to go home. Rather than insist on going through all of them, I asked everyone which issues they think need to be discussed today, and which ones could wait until next week. To give another example, I once wanted to advise a classmate on a not-very-elegant habit she had. It was quite an awkward thing to mention, but I saw her do it many times, and if no one tells her, she would be leaving a bad impression on others, so I felt a moral obligation to tell her if a suitable situation arises. I didn’t keep thinking about it, but after many weeks, I saw her alone in the library, so I went in and asked her if I could tell her something. She said OK. I very politely said, “I think you dress really well, and you’re quite an elegant person. But I noticed you sometimes like to slowly scratch your nose, and it’s kind of surprising to see that from such an elegant person, you know? I just don’t want others to get a negative impression of you because of it. That’s all.” She replied that she indeed has this habit, and that she appreciated my good intentions, and she’ll work on it. 7: Be conservative. This is related to having an attitude of humility and carefulness. We should never think that we are absolutely right. We should always leave some room for the possibility that we are wrong. Icon Source No one likes an arrogant person. When we seem arrogant, then even if our advice is good, the other person will resist or argue simply because they don't like us. Many arguments are just people trying to defeat the other person because they don't like the other person's arrogant demeanor. Logically speaking, how can we ever have 100% complete information on a situation? And how can we possibly see every single perspective that there is to a situation? That’s why we cannot be so definitive about our perspective and suggestions. If we say things like, “You definitely need to do X,” or even “You should do X,” others might think, “Aren’t you a bit overly confident? How can you be so sure?” For example, one time a teacher colleague invited me to observe his English class. I knew that he didn’t have formal training in teaching English to Chinese students like I did, and I gave a lot of advice and industry best practices that I received and learned in my experience. Later, another colleague told me that this teacher felt I was quite arrogant, as if what I said is definitely right, but he felt that not all of the advice was applicable to his situation. This is an example of how overconfidence in attitude makes the other person lose trust in us. I’ve learned from that incident, and now when I give suggestions to others, especially if I’m not that close with them, I try to use conservative wording. I might say, “I noticed this situation, and I just had an idea for your consideration. Maybe it would be helpful if you did X. But my perspective is limited, and I don’t understand the full situation, so it’s just an idea for your consideration.” 8: Be a problem-solver, not a problem-talker. When we bring up a problem or complaint, ideally, we shouldn’t just stop there. We should propose a solution(s) or make a request. If we only bring up problems and complaints, we’ll be a burden to others, and they will want to avoid us. But if we raise a problem and also propose potential solutions, as well as our analysis of which solution is the best, then it’s like we just delivered a gift to them. Icon Source For example, when my mother complained in the past that I was too busy, I was quite annoyed because I didn’t like being so busy either, and I felt like I was already trying my best to manage my time effectively and say no to many things. One time, I decided to take my own advice: instead of being annoyed and complaining about her complaining, I made a request. I said, “I understand that you don’t want to see me so busy. But when you complain about it, it’s not helpful for me. It only makes me feel even more burdened. Instead of telling me to be less busy, could you instead ask me to schedule time for whatever it is that you want me to do? For example, if you want me to clean the basement, you could ask me to spend a day doing that this weekend. Or if you want me to sleep earlier, you could ask me to sleep by a certain time. That would be much more helpful than just telling me to stop being so busy.” She happily accepted my request. To give another example, when I noticed some problems at school, I first thought about potential solutions. I also discussed in private with other teachers and even the principal about my ideas, and then I proposed them in a meeting. In this way, people were more receptive to my suggestions. 9: Observe and adjust. When we are giving our recommendation or having that tough conversation, it’s important to observe other people’s reactions and adjust ourselves accordingly. This requires us to be fully present and to observe the other person’s facial expressions, movements, and body language, all of which give clues to what they’re thinking and feeling. Icon Source We shouldn’t be focused on how we will respond later when they stop talking (and we certainly should not interrupt them), because if we do that, we won’t be giving them our full attention, and they’ll be able to feel that. We also shouldn’t get lost in our own talking such that we forget to observe the listener. For example, I remember one time I proposed an idea at a meeting, and afterwards, there was barely a reaction from anyone. I was quite surprised because I was expecting people to agree with me. I also realized that when I was speaking, I was looking at my PowerPoint slides instead of at the listeners, so I didn’t know what their facial expressions and body language were while I was speaking. That was an awkward situation. There have also been times when I started giving a suggestion, but then the other person would interrupt and start explaining themselves. When that happens, I already know that they are convinced they are right, or they started to become defensive, in which case it’s probably not worth trying to convince them. If they are not in the mood to hear advice right now, then it’s better to keep silent and change the topic. 10: Be patient. There’s a Chinese proverb that goes, “Three feet of ice doesn’t freeze overnight.” In other words, for a situation to become this serious, it took a long time. People have deeply ingrained habits, and these habits are like huge blocks of ice. Melting them away takes time. If we want people to learn new habits and new ways of thinking, it’s like planting a tree. After we plant the seed, we have to continuously water the seed and patiently wait for the seed to grow into a tree. It doesn’t happen in one conversation. Icon Source We shouldn’t think, “I already advised them before, and they didn’t listen, so I’m not going to bother anymore.” We have to be patient and continue to advise them with tact whenever a suitable opportunity arises. For example, I’ve been counseling a student on emotional regulation for a couple months now, and I’ve given countless reminders in daily school life, and each weekly counseling session is basically giving the same message packaged differently. However, I am not impatient because I know that change takes time, and it’s precisely my job to provide that needed reminder whenever an incident happens. Slowly, the ice of the old habit will melt away, and the new habit will grow. He’s already noticeably better than a couple months ago, and I’m sure that as long as we continue what we’re doing, he will continue to improve. Conclusion Giving advice and suggestions is extremely important to maintaining relationships, and it’s one of the best gifts we can give if done well. It is also a big source of conflict if done ineffectively, hence the importance of learning and practicing communication principles. In this article, I’ve shared some principles I’ve learned over the years, but it’s by no means an exhaustive list, so it’s just some ideas for your consideration. Hopefully you’ll find some use from them and enjoy better communication and relationships as a result! Weekly Wisdom #368
- Elevate Relationships With The Five Love Languages and The Four Methods of Befriending
Do you want to improve any of your current relationships, whether they be family, friends, or professional? Are you hoping to make new friendships with others? If so, do you know how to do so? On a related note, do you ever feel like you clearly show love and consideration for the other person, but they don’t seem to appreciate it? If you said yes to any of these questions, then this article may be helpful. Happiness researcher Gretchen Rubin often says, “Ancient philosophers and contemporary scientists agree that strong relationships are a key to happiness, maybe even THE key to happiness.” Around 2500 years ago, the Buddha taught The Four Methods of Befriending (四攝法) to nurture relationships and make friends. In modern times, marriage researcher Gary Chapman discovered the Five Love Languages framework. Comparing the Two Frameworks The Four Methods of Befriending are Giving : giving gifts and hosting guests. More broadly, it includes not just material gifts, but also the giving of time, energy, happiness, comfort, knowledge, and wisdom. Loving words : encouragement, appreciation, praise, and admonishment. Beneficial action : doing things to help them, reduce their burden, relieve their stress, etc. Activities in common : joining them in activities that they like to do. The Five Love Languages are Gifts : big and small; no need for any special reason or occasion; the important thing is the sentiment and thoughtfulness behind the gift. Words of Affirmation : compliments, praise, encouragement and appreciation. It’s more meaningful when it’s specific and thoughtful. Acts of Service : running an errant for them, cooking, doing the chores, and anything else that reduces their workload and stress. Quality Time : giving them your undivided attention, joining them in activities that they enjoy. Touch : holding hands, hugs, a pat on the shoulder, a high five, or even just being close in space. Image Source Did you notice how these two frameworks are almost the same? It is a great example of ancient philosophers and contemporary scientists having the same ideas! The major difference is that the Five Love Languages has touch as a language, while the Four Methods of Befriending does not. This also makes sense since The Five Love Languages focuses on intimate relationships, while the Four Methods of Befriending focuses on all relationships, and touch is not very suitable for those we aren’t close with. We have to be socially and culturally sensitive when it comes to touch. There are also a couple minor differences between the two frameworks. Giving in the Four Methods of Befriending is broader than Gifts in the Five Love Languages. Also, Loving Words is broader than Words of Affirmation because it encompasses giving admonishment and even harsh criticism so long as it comes from a loving intention. It’s also important to note that these methods are not mutually exclusive. One act can have multiple love languages involved. For example, if we give someone a massage while chatting with them, that includes touch, acts of service, quality time, and the giving of time. If write a holiday card and give a small gift, that includes gifts and words of affirmation. Using The Two Frameworks One key insight that Chapman found for the Five Love Languages is that although everyone appreciates every love language, people usually have one or two primary love languages that they prefer. In other words, if two people have different love languages, they might both think that they are showing lots of love and care for the other person, but the other person doesn’t really feel it. Therefore, a key insight is that we need to learn the other person’s top one or two love languages and make conscious effort to love them in their preferred way. Otherwise, we tend to express love using our love language, and as a result, they might feel we are being nice, but they might also feel we aren’t truly loving them (at least not in the way they are hoping for). Example 1: Spouses Famous author and speaker Jay Shetty’s primary love language is gifts. It might be because during his childhood, his mother would always give him the best birthday gifts and surprise parties. However, his wife’s primary love languages are quality time and acts of service. Shetty would put in a ton of effort into giving gifts to his wife, but his wife never seemed to react as happily as he imagined she would. On the other hand, his wife would put in a lot of time and effort to cook healthy gourmet meals for him and want to spend good quality time with him, but he didn’t react with the same level of enthusiasm she was hoping for. After learning about the Five Love Languages, Shetty realized that his wife is much happier to simply go grocery shopping together than to go for a meal at a nice restaurant. His wife also put in more effort into gifts for special occasions, which Shetty appreciated very much. Example 2: Colleagues Let’s say we want to improve our relationships with colleagues. Here, the Four Methods of Befriending would be useful. We don’t even need to think about what their preferred method is (that’s more for intimate relationships); we can use any or all four methods: Giving : say good morning to them in the morning and goodbye when leaving the office, bring little snacks for everyone to share, give holiday cards or little gifts. Loving Words : give them encouragement, praise, thank-you notes, and timely advice. Beneficial Action : look for ways to help them with their work or reduce their stress. Activities in Common : attend social events together, chat with them and give them our attention and interest. Example 3: Friends We may not see our friends every day like we do with family and colleagues, but we can still use the Four Methods of Befriending. We can give gifts on special occasions, encourage each other when we chat about our lives, help each other when needed, and spend time together doing things that we mutually enjoy together. Conclusion We could all probably do a better job at nurturing relationships, which would be very beneficial for everyone in the relationships. For intimate relationships, it’s important to know their primary one or two love languages so that you can express love in their preferred way. For non-intimate relationships, using any and all of the Four Methods of Befriending would help. Weekly Wisdom #367
- TCM: The Five Elements Profiles
Welcome to this article series on Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). The aim of this series is to provide you with foundational and practical knowledge of TCM that you can use to improve your own health at home in daily life. The recommendations in this series are simple, accessible, and mostly free. After all, good health should be something that is accessible to everyone! Here is a clickable table of contents for this series: Introduction and Foundation The Five Elements Profiles Food and Cooking The Five Major Organs The Nine Body Constitutions The Body Clock Common Treatments from a Practitioner My Experience with TCM Health Advice From Doctors At A Chinese Medicine Hospital Sleep Tips from Traditional Chinese Medicine Emotions and Health This article is Part 2: The Five Elements Profiles Last time, we talked about foundational knowledge of TCM: Yin Yang, Qi, Blood, and the five elements. Recall that the five elements is a framework that connects the natural world to our bodies in terms of organs, emotions, flavors, colors, and more. Image Source: PowerPoint Wizardry by Yours Truly This article will go in-depth into the five elements. Here is a clickable table of contents to help you navigate the article: Part 1: Characteristics 1.1 🌳 Characteristics 1.2 🔥 Characteristics 1.3 🌱 Characteristics 1.4 🛠 Characteristics 1.5 🌊 Characteristics Part 2: Organs 2.1 🌳 Organs: Liver and Gallbladder 2.2 🔥 Organs: Heart and Small Intestines 2.3 🌱 Organs: Stomach and Spleen 2.4 🛠 Organs: Lungs and Large Intestines 2.5 🌊 Organs: Kidneys and Bladder Part 3: Emotions 3.1 🌳 Emotions: Compassion and Anger 3.2 🔥 Emotions: Joy and Sadness 3.3 🌱 Emotions: Openness and Worry 3.4 🛠 Emotions: Courage and Sorrow 3.5 🌊 Emotions: Determination and Fear Part 4: Personality 4.1 🌳 Personality: Constant Growth 4.2 🔥 Personality: Life of the Party 4.3 🌱 Personality: The Nurturer 4.4 🛠 Personality: The Well-Sharpened Sword 4.5 🌊 Personality: Goes with the Flow Part 5: Body Types 5.1 🌳 Body Type 5.2 🔥 Body Type 5.3 🌱 Body Type 5.4 🛠 Body Type 5.5 🌊 Body Type Part 6: Balancing Each Element 6.1 🌳 Balancing Wood 6.2 🔥 Balancing Fire 6.3 🌱 Balancing Earth 6.4 🛠 Balancing Metal 6.5 🌊 Balancing Water Conclusion --- Part 1: Characteristics 1.1 🌳 Characteristics The wood element season is spring; this is when all the new plants are growing. As expected, the wood element’s color is green, just like spring. The taste associated with wood is sour because fruits are still new and unripe in the spring, and so they have a sour taste. 1.2 🔥 Characteristics The fire element season is summer; this is when we have the most amount of heat and sun. As expected, the color associated with fire is red. Intuitively, you might think fire has the spicy taste, but the fire element is actually associated with the bitter taste. Here’s a good way to remember this: During spring, plants are still small and often get eaten by bugs, but as they grow bigger in the summer, they produce bitter chemicals that make them less appealing to bugs. 1.3 🌱 Characteristics The earth element is linked to the late summer season. This is the time when fruits ripen and become sweet, hence the taste associated with earth is sweet. The color associated with earth is yellow because yellow grass comes out late summer. 1.4 🛠 Characteristics The metal element is associated to the season of autumn, which is all about the falling leaves. Falling leaves represent letting go of things we don’t need and only holding onto the necessary things. The color of the metal element is white, which symbolizes death. The taste associated with metal is pungent and aromatic, which you’ll notice in fragrant spices like garlic, ginger, and basil. The sound of the metal element is crying since the trees are sad to let go of their leaves in autumn. The idea of metal being an element might seem confusing, but the reason metal is used is because this element can shape other elements, just as how a knife can shape food. You can also think of metal as similar to the element of air. The metal element is associated with dryness and the skin because there is cold and dry wind in autumn. 1.5 🌊 Characteristics The water element season is winter, which is a time of survival, isolation, and reflection. The colors associated with water are blue and black. The taste is salty just like ocean water and sea vegetables. Part 2: Organs 2.1 🌳 Organs The Liver and the Gallbladder are the wood element organs. They both detox the body and nourish Blood, which then strengthens the hair and nails. 2.2 🔥 Organs The fire element has two organs: the Heart and Small Intestines , both of which play a big role in our emotions. The Heart is the emotion center. The Small Intestines produce serotonin, which regulates mood and happiness in the body. Similar to how the Small Intestines separates nutrients from waste, it also helps our mind to differentiate from right and wrong or good and bad. 2.3 🌱 Organs The Stomach and Spleen are the earth element organs. Just as we can throw waste onto the soil, and then the earth turns it into nourishment for plants, our digestive organs transform food into nourishment for the body. In TCM, the Stomach holds the food, while the Spleen is responsible for digestion and nutrient absorption. In other words, the TCM Spleen includes some of the functions of the western idea of pancreas and small intestines. 2.4 🛠 Organs The two organs associated with the metal element are the Lungs and Large Intestines . The Lungs bring in nourishment (oxygen), while the Large Intestines let go of waste. The Lungs are also related to the immune system according to TCM. 2.5 🌊 Organs The two organs associated with the water element are the Kidneys and the Bladder . The Kidneys filtrate water, while the Bladder eliminates water. In TCM, the Kidneys are also related to our reproductive organs. Part 3: Emotions Western medicine tends to view emotions as separate from the physical body, but TCM explains that emotions are connected to our organs. Therefore, if we have trouble with a certain emotion, then healing the organ associated with that emotion will help us with that emotion. Amazing! Image Source: Yours Truly When an element is in balance, we experience the positive emotions associated with it. When an element is out of balance, we experience the negative emotions associated with it. As the next section, personality, will explain, each of us has one or two elements that are strongest in our body constitution, meaning we are prone to different emotions based on our innate constitution. 3.1 🌳 Emotions Positive emotions: love, compassion, and growth Negative emotions: frustration, anger; procrastination, and indecision. Anger and frustration relate to an unbalanced Liver, while indecision and procrastination relate to an unbalanced Gallbladder 3.2 🔥 Emotions Positive emotions : joy, happiness, and love. Negative emotions : sadness, anxiety, overjoy Notice that the fire emotions are all felt in the chest, near the Heart. Overjoy is also considered an unhealthy fire emotion because it leads to a big low afterwards. 3.3 🌱 Emotions Positive emotions : trust and openness Negative emotions : worry and overthinking The area where you feel the earth element in your body is the solar plexus (under the chest, above the belly button). When people start to worry, their solar plexus tighten, so breathing fully to the abdomen helps to relax worry. 3.4 🛠 Emotions Positive emotions : connection and courage Negative emotions : sorrow and attachment An example of attachment is losing someone or something you love and then being unable to let go of the past. 3.5 🌊 Emotions Positive emotions : willpower and calm Negative emotions : fear and shock; resentment, jealousy, suspicion When water is in balance, you can do whatever must be done. When the Kidneys are out of balance, people feel fear or shock. When the Bladder is out of balance, people hold on to resentment and grudges over seemingly small things from a long time ago. They are also prone to jealousy and suspicion. Part 4: Personality We all have all five elements in our bodies, but most of us have one or two dominant ones. Depending on which one or two elements are dominant in your body, you tend to have different personalities. Note that you could acquire characteristics of other elements if that element becomes unbalanced. For example, if I am an earth person, then I would naturally be very nurturing towards others. But if my Liver gets hurt, then I might start to have anger issues. You can take this quiz to find out which element(s) you are, or keep on reading and figure it out yourself. When thinking about your element, think about what’s been natural to you when you were healthy as opposed to only your current situation. As with the emotions section, the strengths will appear if the element is in balance, and the weaknesses will appear if the element is out of balance. 4.1 🌳 Personality A typical wood personality person is always climbing for the top, just like how a tree keeps trying to grow taller. Strengths : goal-setter, high-achiever, planner, gets things done Weaknesses : over-achiever; gets impatient, irritable, or frustrated easily; stubborn (my way or the highway) 4.2 🔥 Personality A typical fire person is usually very passionate and warm, just like fire. Strengths : passionate, fun, and charismatic Weaknesses : easily gets distracted or bored, doesn't like being alone, might not keep their word. 4.3 🌱 Personality A typical earth person is a nurturing and compassionate person, just like how the earth nourishes all living beings. Strengths : loyal, empathetic, great at resolving conflicts, and great at forming deep and long-term relationships. Weaknesses : prone to worry and overthinking, sensitive to criticism, and might get taken advantage of by others. 4.4 🛠 Personality A metal person is like a well-sharpened sword: very meticulous and efficient. They are not spontaneous, and they dislike disorder Strengths : dependable, hardworking, and disciplined. Weaknesses : difficulties opening up and sharing their feelings in close relationships; prone to feeling sad, misunderstood, or lonely. 4.5 🌊 Personality A water person is able to go with the flow, just like water. Strengths : easygoing, creative, self-reflective, and artistic; When in balance, they have strong willpower and determination, and they are seekers of wisdom. Weaknesses : when unbalanced, they are prone to self-doubt and fear of failure, which might make them have low motivation. Part 5: Body Types Image Source 5.1 🌳 Body Type Wood people are usually lean and slim with broad shoulders and a straight back. They tend to have a long face and olive skin tone. 5.2 🔥 Body Type A fire person tends to have a heart shaped face, smaller hands and feet, broad shoulders, wide teeth, and a slightly pointed head. Their hair may be curly or thinning, and their skin complexion tends to be reddish. 5.3 🌱 Body Type An earth person tends to have a pear-shaped body with rounded buttocks and a strong body frame. Their face is typically round with a wide jaw, their skin has a yellowish tone. 5.4 🛠 Body Type A metal person tends to have broad shoulders, a squarish face with defined facial features, pale skin, a flat Stomach, and maybe a smaller body. They usually have a strong voice. 5.5 🌊 Body Type A water person tends to have a round baby face, soft skin, narrow shoulders, and a long spine. They tend to have a larger belly. Part 6: Balancing Each Element When an element gets out of balance in our body, we will experience some negative symptoms. We can re-balance the elements using lifestyle factors such as food, exercise, and rest. For further details, check out Part 3 of this TCM series on food and Part 4 on organs. 6.1 🌳 Balancing Wood Out-of-Balance Symptoms : Getting stressed easily, tightness in the neck and shoulders, headaches, short temper, and often waking up between 1AM to 3AM. Lifestyle Tips : Keep the Qi moving through vigorous exercises and sports; have enough deep sleep to prevent burnout; do restful activities such as meditation and yoga. Food : Eat more sour flavors such as lemon/lime, oranges, tomatoes, and olives. Also eat more green foods such as leafy greens, beans, and avocados. 6.2 🔥 Balancing Fire Out-of-Balance Symptoms : mild anxiety, lacking joy, difficulty sleeping, vivid dreams, poor Blood circulation, and spontaneous sweating. Lifestyle Tips : Do relaxation activities such as meditation, breathing exercises, and yoga; Set aside time to wind-down and relax before sleep; Stay cool in hot weather. Food : Eat more bitter flavors. Many leafy greens have bitterness, such as kale, arugula, lettuce, and broccoli. Other foods with bitterness include asparagus, celery, parsley, bitter melon, and tea. Eating red foods also helps, such as tomatoes, carrots, strawberries, raspberries, and red-skinned apples. 6.3 🌱 Balancing Earth Out-of-Balance Symptoms : Digestive problems, excessive burping or gas, poor appetite, cravings for sweet foods, weight gain, fatigue especially around 3PM, mental fog especially after waking up, and poor muscle strength. Lifestyle Tips : Walking is a suitable exercise for earth because it is energizing and also helps you clear your mind. Do activities to calm your mind and worries, such as meditation, journaling, yoga, or tai chi. Food : To balance earth, you need to strengthen your digestive organs. You can do that by eating well-cooked and warm-temperature foods. Naturally sweet flavored foods, not processed sugary foods, are good for the digestive system. Examples include whole grains, potatoes, sweet potatoes, pumpkin, peas, and many fruits. But don’t eat too many raw fruits because that raw and cold energy hurts the Stomach. Cooking your fruits would be better. Yellow foods are also helpful, such as lemon, soy beans, barley, summer squash, and potatoes. 6.4 🛠 Balancing Metal Out-of-Balance Symptoms : Easily catching colds and flus, shortness of breath, congested nose, constipation, dry skin, tiredness, and grief. Lifestyle Tips : To balance metal, it’s important to strengthen the Lungs, which circulate air and Qi around the body. You can do breathing exercises or Qi Gong. Since metal people are prone to sadness, it’s extra important to maintain an active social life. Participating in community activities is a great way to do that. Food : Eat more pungent flavored foods such as onions, chives, garlic, fresh ginger, chili peppers, cinnamon, and wasabi. Naturally white foods also help, such as daikon radish, turnip, cauliflower, potatoes, and mushrooms. This does not include processed foods like white bread and white sugar. It’s also important to avoid mucus-inducing foods such as dairy, sweets, and fried foods. 6.5 🌊 Balancing Water Out-of-Balance Symptoms : Aches in joints, especially in the lower back, knees, or ankles; a feeling of heaviness or swelling due to fluid retention; memory problems; hearing difficulties; and cravings for salty foods. Lifestyle Tips : To balance water, it’s important to support the Kidneys by drinking enough water and avoiding stimulants like coffee, cola, and energy drinks. Water people feel good near water, so swimming in the ocean or even a bath is great for them. Do exercises that are calming and have low impact on the joints, such as yoga and Pilates. Food : Eat more naturally salty foods such as seaweed/kelp, miso, millet, barley, fermented products, pickles, parsley, and celery. Black or blue foods also help, such as seaweed/kelp, black beans, black rice, blackberries, blueberries, and eggplant. You can also add some natural sea salt (which is much better than processed table salt according to TCM) to your cooking, but don't overdo it. Conclusion Our bodies are connected to nature via the five elements framework. That means our organs, emotions, and food are all inter-connected. When we live in accordance with nature, then health occurs. When we lose our natural balance, then illness starts. This article explained the five elements in terms of characteristics, organs, emotions, personality, body type, and balancing tips. After reading this article, I hope you can identify your dominant element and take simple actions to support your health. The next article will go into depth about food and cooking.
.jpg)











